Since 2010, 201 anti-Sharia legislation bills have actually been presented in 43 states. In 2017 alone, 14 states introduced an anti-Sharia law bill, v Texas and also Arkansas it spreads widely the legislation.

You are watching: Cases of sharia law in america


One of the most successful far-right conspiracies to achieve mainstream viability, the mass hysteria neighboring a so-called risk of “Sharia law” in the United says is mostly the work of anti-Muslim groups such as the American liberty Law facility and ACT for America (ACT), an SPLC-designated hate group. In June, so-called “anti-Sharia” rallies organized by ACT were held throughout the country and attractive white nationalists, equipped right-wing militias and even neo-Nazis. 

David Yerushalmi, the father of the anti-Sharia movement, serves as co-founder that the American freedom Law Center (AFLC) and also General Counsel that the Center for security Policy. AFLC has pushed the initiative, American regulations for American courts (ALAC, principally authored by Yerushalmi, because 2010Politicians in just eight states have not joined this concerted job of stoking are afraid of Islam. Man Rodgers, the previous executive director of ACT because that America, the largest grassroots anti-Muslim team in the country, concedes the there is no real affect of Islam in courts but says, “Before the train gets too much down the tracks it’s time to placed up the block.”

The bulk of anti-Sharia regulation introduced throughout the country incorporates the American laws for American Courts model legislation published on the American Public plan Alliance’s (APPA) website. This sort of language typically includes a i prohibiting foreign law in American courts whereby it would result in a dispute with rights guaranteed through the constitution of the state or the united States. This legislation is totally useless — the U.S. Constitution already expressly denies government to any foreign law. In fact, Yerushalmi himself admits:

If this thing passed in every state without any kind of friction, that would have not offered its purpose. The function was heuristic — come get civilization asking this question, ‘what is Shariah?’

What is “Sharia law”?

The term “Sharia law” is a misnomer because sharia is not actually a law or a universally-defined legit code, but a collection of guiding principles to living a ethical life collection out in the Quran. Numerous representatives, in their development of anti-“Sharia law” bills, point out the “invasion” the ‘sharia law’ and the urgent must stop the from beginning American courts.

Upon more inspection that Yerushalmi’s campaign to develop a fear of Sharia, that is no so far fetched the the basic public is falling because that it. The SPLC has actually previously documented the problematic findings of simple Google searches such as, “what is sharia,” and “sharia and the united state constitution.” Anti-Muslim propaganda stand for the bulk of the findings.

Similar to other spiritual scriptures, sharia might be considered in court problem (although rarely and also infrequently), including family disputes and also torts with foreign countries, yet federal and also state laws always take precedence. Still, Yerushalmi has drafted number of iterations of anti-Sharia bills. In 2006, he drafted anti-Sharia law with his organization, culture of americans for nationwide Existence (SANE), which stated:

“It shall it is in a felony punishable by twenty years in prison to knowingly act in furtherance of, or to support the, adherence to Shari"a.”

Speaking ~ above the subject of Muslims, he added: 

The Mythical ‘moderate’ Muslim … the Muslim that embraces traditional Islam yet wants a serene coexistence through the West, is efficiently non-existent.

However, in 2010, a referee in new Jersey made an error in his translate of this diverse spiritual legal tradition, and Yerushalmi has actually exploited this to offer his larger anti-Muslim movement ever since.

In 2010, a Moroccan Muslim woman, who entered into one arranged marital relationship with she Moroccan Muslim husband just two month before, asked for a restraining order versus him, alleging he had actually been raping her. The husband allegedly claimed he didn’t think he was doing anything wrong due to the fact that they to be married and also “this is according to our religion.” The new Jersey referee did not give the restraining order, citing lack of criminal intent.

The new Jersey Appellate Court reversed the decision shortly after, recognizing that the factor to consider of religious beliefs is no applicable without the authorization the American law. In other words, the U.S. Constitution prevents any type of foreign law from mainly being supplied in the joined States.

Nevertheless, the anti-Sharia movement led by Yerushalmi, AFLC, APPA and various other anti-Muslim organizations have actually taken advantage of this overruled decision in their American laws for American Courts initiative instead of finding out from the short-lived mistake of one brand-new Jersey judge.

The harm of anti-Sharia legislation

“Anti-Sharia” bills space rarely explicitly labeled as such. Many legislators include the expression ‘foreign law,’ and also present bills together the systems to a larger influence of all international countries and religions. However, APPA explicitly says this law was created, “to protect American citizens’ constitution rights against the infiltration and incursion of foreign laws and foreign legal doctrines, especially Islamic Sharia Law.”

It is not simply the drafting of this legislation that is problematic, but also that anti-Muslim establishments are working directly with legislators to happen this kind of bill. V entities prefer ACT and Center for Security plan on the frontlines the this movement, castle are likewise heavily raising anti-Muslim rhetoric.

The rise in legislation and also anti-Muslim rhetoric within state legislatures is not without consequence for Muslim communities. In fact, dislike crimes versus Muslims increased by 67 percent according come FBI statistics exit in 2015. In March, 3 Muslim college student attempted come visit Rep. Man Bennett in the State Capitol in Oklahoma City. Before meeting v them, Bennett insisted castle fill the end a questionnaire about Islam which contained questions like, “The Koran, the sunna of Mohammed and Sharia regulation of all colleges say that the husband have the right to beat his wife. Do you agree with him?”

Experts including professors, attorneys, politicians, and also the American Bar association (ABA) have been fast to denounce anti-Sharia regulation bills. In an answer to one uptick in anti-“Sharia law” bills introduced in 2010 and also 2011, the ABA published a official letter the dissent, speak in part:

"The American Bar combination opposes commonwealth or state legislations that impose blanket prohibitions on factor to consider or usage by court or arbitral tribunals of the whole body of legislation or theory of a certain religion,” adding, “… American courts will certainly not use Sharia or other rules (real or perceived) that space contrary come our public policy, including, because that instance, rule that are incompatible through our notions of sex equality."

The ABA further debated the pertains to of extremely publicizing this form of legislation. The mass hysteria developed by these organizations and also further perpetuated by politicians at state and also federal levels, is alarming. The misconstrued expertise of both Sharia and also the United says constitution through these teams has seek to develop an actionable goal of exterminating Islam. Some states, including Tennessee, have explicitly named ‘Sharia organizations’ and Muslims, the enemy.

See more: Define Pro Life And Pro Choice '? What Does 'Pro

“The risk from sharia-based jihad and also terrorism gift a real and also present peril to the lawful administration of this state and to the serene enjoyment the citizenship through the residents of this state;” adding, it further authorizes the attorney basic to designate “Sharia organizations,” identified as “two (2) or much more persons conspiring come support, or exhilaration in concert in support of, sharia or in furtherance of the imposition of sharia within any type of state or are of the united States. Anyone who offers material assistance or resources to a designated Sharia organization might be charged v a felony and face approximately 15 year in jail.”

Driven by dislike groups, the ALAC plan has developed unfounded fear, and has sought come demonize Islam and American Muslims throughout the country through legislation and also rhetoric.