Though Pope Francis has endorsed same-sex polite unions and also LGBT+ rights, he proceeds to perpetuate discrimination versus LGBT+ civilization within the clergy and also laity. What"s behind the contradiction?


"Who am i to judge happy people?" Pope Francis apparently said to journalists on a flight ago to Rome native Rio de Janeiro ~ a resounding people Youth work in July 2013.

You are watching: Catholic church’s stance on gay marriage

Seven years later, the pontiff has actually returned to the controversial subject of homosexuality in the Catholic Church. In Francesco, a new documentary film about the pope through Evgeny Afineevsky, he says: "Homosexual civilization have a best to it is in in a family. Castle are youngsters of God and have a best to a family. Nobody should be thrown out or it is in made miserable over it."

Nobody? even Catholic priests and also believers? What"s specific is the the Catholic Church"s method to homosexuality is complete of conflict and dual standards. After ~ all, the very same pope who has actually now endorsed same-sex polite unions is against same-sex marriage. The very same pope who states that world should not be do "miserable" because of their sex-related orientation is against gay men joining the clergy.


Pope Francis has actually said there is "no room" for homosexuality in the Catholic Church

At the very least the pope is continuous in his inconsistency. When he was serving together the archbishop the Buenos Aires from 1998 come 2013, he campaigned for same-sex polite unions — however mainly for this reason he could aid prevent LGBT+ human being from gift granted the appropriate to marry. His strategy backfired: In 2010, Argentina became the first Latin American country to legalization same-sex marriage. Numerous countries around the human being have do the same selection in the following decade, consisting of Germany in 2017.

No ar for homosexuality in the Catholic Church

Within the Catholic Church, however, homosexuality remains taboo. In October 2015,the pope fired a gay polishing priestwho had actually come out in spectacular fashion shortly before a crucial summit on the family.

In 2018, in a series of conversations v the Spanish missionary Fernando Prado which were released under the title The stamin of a Vocation: Consecrated Life Today, the pontiff said there to be "no room" because that homosexuality in the Catholic Church. "For this reason, the Church urges the persons with this rooted propensity not be welcomed into (priestly) set or consecrated life," that said.

In Germany, however, the main Committee the German Catholics has referred to as for "the power of blessings not to it is in withheld" from same-sex couples for years. "We are campaigning for an official rite because that blessing homosexual couples to it is in developed," it stated in an main statement in November 2019.

Read more:How a church in Germany posthumously reinstated a happy clergyman

Theo Hipp, a priest based in the southwestern city that Mannheim, think the pope"s latest relocate is an attempt to revive the difficult conversation about homosexuality in the Catholic Church.

"If it were up to him, Pope Francis would certainly say that every priest and also pastor has to stand up for homosexuals having actually the ideal to live in dignity and also with legit protection," stated Hipp. However, this view would have wide-ranging results on both the Catholic Church and the world of politics.

Hipp is really familiar through the Catholic Church"s operations at the worlelafilador.netide level. That prepares priests who have involved work in Germany due to the fact that of a absence of German clergy. Lock come from all over the world, from places like Poland, Brazil, India and Tanzania.

Many Catholics in Africa, Asia not ready to expropriate homosexuality

Half that the world"s approximated 1.3 billion Catholics live in the Americas, an especially Latin America. When 20% that Europe"s populace considers itself Catholic, this number is on the decline. However, according to the Vatican"s news company Agenzia Fides, there space a growing variety of Catholics in Asia and an especially in Africa, whereby some 18% of the populace is Catholic.

But it"s in these growing Catholic communities in Asia and Africa the the pope"s recent words have actually been the very least welcome, said Hipp. "African Catholics, or believer in the center East, fight the roof as soon as someone says that same-sex partnerships have to be equal to marriage," that said, adding that castle — prefer the pope — aren"t prepared to fully accept homosexuality in the Catholic Church.

See more: Chris Rock Bring The Pain Transcript, Chris Rock Bigger And Blacker Script

Read more:Opinion: has actually the Catholic Church had actually its day?

Despite the basic opposition the dogmatists in the Vatican and also conservative leaders in Asia and also Africa, Hipp think it"s important that the church proceed to debate the problem of homosexuality.

"This will lead to a procedure of clear up that provides clear that in the church us are likewise responsible because that inhumanity through our dogmatism," that said, adding: "It"s great that us don"t have any type of political power."

Alexander Vogt, the head the the group that represents the lesbian and also gay interests of the conservative CDU and CSU next in the German parliament, can agree v this. That told the he was very glad around the pope"s latest words, saying the it to be "something we have actually waited because that a long time."

"He has actually made one or another remark in the past that verified at least that the is compassionate toward gays and also lesbians," claimed Vogt. "I felt ideal away expect for some words that regret about the suffering and pain the teachings the the church have actually caused in the past centuries for gays and lesbians."