We collected a perform of claims with sanctuary—and anti-sanctuary—policies. However it to be more facility than you could think.

You are watching: Center for immigration studies sanctuary cities map


U.S. Immigration and also Customs Enforcement police officers arrest an undocumented mexico immigrant throughout a raid in Bushwick, Brooklyn, in April of 2018.

(Photo: john Moore/Getty Images)

Florida will most likely pass what many contact an "anti-sanctuary" invoice this week: The bill, bitterly battled over in the state's legislature, will make that illegal because that Florida police policemans not come cooperate through with Immigration and Customs Enforcement and will inflict penalties—including removal native office—on any officials who enacts sanctuary-city policies.

With Florida poised to become the latest state come enact a state-wide regulation on sanctuary policies, we set out to make a map of says that have comparable anti-sanctuary laws, and also states that have declared themselves "sanctuaries."

It showed harder 보다 you can think. While the notion of "sanctuary"—sanctuary cities, sanctuary counties, sanctuary states—appears in the news frequently, there's no legal meaning of, or widespread covenant on, what qualifies together one. And also there's a most misinformation out there around what sanctuary policies do.

There's much less disagreement around qualifies as an anti-sanctuary policy: favor Florida, a collection of various other states have actually laws where regional authorities' full cooperation with ice agents is mandatory, making the illegal for any type of city or nation to enact sanctuary policies. That renders a map that anti-sanctuary policies less complicated to make:

If and when Florida's proposed new law goes into effect, 20 percent of claims will have anti-sanctuary policies.

The anti-sanctuary movement at the state level began in 2009, mainly as backlash come a pro-sanctuary activity that started at the city level in the late 1980s and ticked earlier up in the 2000s during an upswing in illegal immigration.

Disagreement about How plenty of Sanctuary states Exist

Depending on that you ask, the united States might have end a dozen sanctuary claims or as few as zero. It every comes down to what the person answering considers come constitute as a sanctuary policy.

According come the facility for immigration Studies, among the most significant anti-immigration advocacy institutions in the country, there are eight states that count as "sanctuary jurisdictions" together of April the 2019.

"My working an interpretation of a sanctuary is a jurisdiction that has actually an ordinance, or an executive order, or a policy, or also an articulable exercise of interfering with ICE's initiatives to eliminate their charges," states Jessica Vaughn, CIS's director of plan studies who aided create the organization's list of sanctuary jurisdictions.

CIS's map of these jurisdictions (states, counties, and cities) is typically cited by newspapers and also magazine report on sanctuary policies. Here's what that looks like:


Other organizations and experts disagree v CIS's list.

"According to how we specify , California can be the just one," says Krsna Avila, an immigrants' rights other at the Immigrant Legal source Center, a pro-immigration research and also advocacy group.

The ILRC has actually its very own map, which uses a gradient that sanctuary-ness, rating the level to which local jurisdictions cooperate v ICE. Here's what that map watch like:

Understanding What 'Sanctuary' Means

Some people—often influenced by alarmist rhetoric from anti-immigration politicians—believe the sanctuary jurisdictions are locations where undocumented immigrant are cost-free from deportation or arrest. No such location exists almost everywhere in the U.S. There's no state, town, or also city block wherein ICE agents can not arrest an undocumented person: even in san Francisco, the first city to declare itself a "sanctuary city" in 1989—which sits in the middle of California, which claimed itself a sanctuary state in 2017—ICE arrested over 150 civilization in just one week in 2018.

So what, then, walk "sanctuary" mean?

Living in the country as one undocumented immigrant is a civil offense, no a crime: That means that it's not up to police—state, county, or city cops—to enforce immigration laws. That project is left to commonwealth agents: specific ICE. However, ice cream agents can't be everywhere at once, so they often request that local legislation enforcement agents assist them bring out your mandate. This wake up in a variety of ways: ICE might ask police to let their agents interview someone in jail, deputize police police officers to do immigration-related arrests, or request that police hold someone in jail until ICE agents have the right to come arrest them.

Sanctuary plans seek to limit the level to which regional police occupational with ICE. For circumstances in California, one of the country's the strongest sanctuary jurisdictions, it's illegal because that state and local regulation enforcement to use any kind of funds or resources to “investigate, interrogate, detain, detect, or arrest people for immigrant enforcement purposes."

That walk not typical that California police do not cooperate with ICE: Federal legislation mandates that when police arrest someone almost everywhere in the country—including every sanctuary states and cities—they send the person's fingerprints and other information to the department of countryside Security, which monitor ICE. Ice can likewise procure warrants that compel regional police policemans to detain suspects want by the commonwealth government.

Multiple courts have actually ruled, however, that neighborhood jurisdictions have actually the discretion come deny details requests ice cream makes. According to Avila and also ILRC, there are six discretionary locations wherein regional jurisdictions can pick not come cooperate through ICE:

Local jurisdictions can decrease what are called "detainer requests," wherein ice requests a regional jail host someone also after castle should've to be released so that ICE agents can come re-arrest them.They can decrease to notify ICE as soon as a human being ICE is targeting is going to be released from jail.They can refuse what's dubbed a 287(g) contract, which allows ice to deputize local regulation enforcement to make immigration-related arrests.They can refuse to provide ICE the use of a jurisdiction's existing detention facilities.They can instruct police never to ask around a person's immigrant status.They have the right to refuse to grant ICE agents access to jails to interview doubt if the ice agents perform not have actually a warrant.

Putting that All on a Map

The concern of what says count as sanctuaries then comes under to a issue of degrees: How numerous different varieties of ice requests need to a state refuse for us to consider that state a sanctuary state?

For Vaughn and CIS, the most crucial thing toward deciding whether or no a state is sanctuary is even if it is or no it honors detainer requests. "A detainer is the main tool supplied by ice to obtain custody that criminal aliens because that deportation," CIS's sanctuary map explainer says.

That's why CIS includes Colorado and new Mexico top top its map, even though neither state has a law or executive, management order producing anything close to a sanctuary policy. However, essentially every county jail in both those states will decrease ICE detainer requests. This is because civil civil liberties groups brought lawsuits in Colorado and new Mexico in 2014 that doubted the constitutionality that detainer requests. In the Colorado suit, a ar judge rule in 2018 that a sheriff can not legally keep someone in jail ~ a judge had actually ordered that person released (or if the police otherwise had no reason to hold them other than a detainer request). A referee in new Mexico walk even further, and ruled that regional law enforcement is minimal in information they can share v ICE. As such, almost all the sheriffs managing county jails in both states determined that, in stimulate to limit legal liability and vulnerability to similar suits, they would refuse ice detainer request that came without warrants.

CIS consists of Massachusetts for a comparable reason: In 2017, the state's supreme Court ruled that detainer requests are unconstitutional, equating them to arbitrary detention.

The perform of says that have actually actually pass sanctuary-like laws is short: California, Connecticut, Illinois, Oregon, and also Vermont. Additionally, new Jersey, Rhode Island, and also Washington State room all currently under executive, management orders that limit the degree to which local legislation enforcement cooperates with ICE.

However, having actually laws or executive orders developing sanctuary policies can not be sufficient for a state be considered a sanctuary if law enforcement deserve to still cooperate through ICE in far-ranging ways.

"Some jurisdictions that contact themselves sanctuaries don't satisfy that definition, since they're act it together a sort of posturing—'Oh, we're a welcome city, we're a sanctuary—but they actually carry out cooperate v ICE," Vaughn says.

For instance, CIS go not think about Connecticut a sanctuary state, even though the state passed a legislation limiting collaboration with ice in 2013. Connecticut still communicates and cooperates enough with ICE that CIS doesn't counting it as a sanctuary.

That gets us to our very own map. Right here it is:

To make our perform of sanctuary states, we decided that just three states have actually laws ~ above the publications that have actually significantly minimal cooperation with ICE: California, Oregon, and Vermont. On our map, we think about these the truest sanctuary states.

Next, we taken into consideration states that have sanctuary-like policies or executive, management orders in ar that limit collaboration with ICE, however not come the same degree as the says we consider sanctuaries. These states, with restricted sanctuary, room Connecticut, Illinois, new Jersey, Rhode Island, and Washington.

See more: Day The Declaration Of Independence Was Signed ? United States Declaration Of Independence

Finally, we note the three states that have actually court decision somehow inspiring or compelling regional jurisdictions no to respect detainer requests: Colorado, Massachusetts, and new Mexico.

Sanctuary StatesImmigration and Customs EnforcementThe department Of countryside SecurityCourtsImmigrantsMaps