Hillary and Bill Clinton at a Clinton global Initiative occasion in new York City in 2014.Credit...John Moore/Getty Images

The kingdom the Saudi Arabia donated an ext than $10 million. Through a foundation, for this reason did the son-in-law that a previous Ukrainian chairman whose federal government was extensively criticized for corruption and the killing of journalists. A Lebanese-Nigerian developer with large business interests added as lot as $5 million.

You are watching: Clinton foundation scandal new york times

For year the Bill, Hillary and Chelsea Clinton structure thrived largely on the generosity of foreign donors and also individuals who provided hundreds of countless dollars to the global charity. But now, as Mrs. Clinton seeks the White House, the capital of the sprawling philanthropy has end up being an Achilles’ hoe for her campaign and, if she is victorious, potentially her management as well.

With Mrs. Clinton encountering accusations that favoritism toward Clinton structure donors throughout her time as secretary the state, previous President bill Clinton told foundation employees ~ above Thursday the the organization would no much longer accept foreign or corporate donations have to Mrs. Clinton victory in November.

But if the move might avoid the awkwardness of Mr. Clinton jetting roughly the people asking for money when his mam is president, it did not solve a much more pressing question: how her administration would take care of longtime donors seeking assist from the joined States, or whose interests might dispute with the country’s own.


The Clinton structure has welcomed tens of numerous dollars from countries that the State department — before, during and after Mrs. Clinton’s time as secretary — criticized for their documents on sex discrimination and other human-rights issues. The countries include Saudi Arabia, the joined Arab Emirates, Qatar, Kuwait, Oman, Brunei and also Algeria.

Saudi Arabia has been a specifically generous benefactor. The kingdom gave between $10 million and $25 million come the Clinton Foundation. (Donations are typically reported in wide ranges, not certain amounts.) At the very least $1 million more was donated by friend of Saudi Arabia, which was co-founded by a Saudi prince.

Saudi Arabia also presents Washington v a complicated diplomatic relationship full of strain. The kingdom is viewed as a bulwark come deter Iranian adventurism across the region and has actually been a companion in the fight versus terrorism across the Persian Gulf and wider Middle East.

At the same time, though, American officials have long worried about Saudi Arabia’s suspected function in promoting a hard-line strain of Islam, which has actually some adherents who have been connected to violence. Saudi public representative deny any links to terrorism groups, but critics point to Saudi charities that fund organizations suspected of ties to militant cells.


Brian Fallon, a spokesman because that the Clinton campaign, stated the Clintons and the structure had constantly been careful around donors. “The policies that administrate the foundation’s activities during Hillary Clinton’s tenure as secretary that state already went far beyond legal requirements,” he claimed in a statement, “and yet the foundation submitted to even much more rigorous standards once Clinton claimed her candidacy for president, and is pledging come go also further if she wins.”


Mrs. Clinton, in ~ a news conference in 2015, joined the structure when she left the state department and also stepped under in 2015 before beginning her campaign.Credit...Andrew Burton/Getty Images

Mrs. Clinton’s opponent, Donald J. Trump, could challenge his own complications if he becomes president, with investments abroad and also hundreds of millions of dollars in actual estate debt — financial location that could be affected by move he renders in the White House. And also on Friday, Paul Manafort resigned as chairman of the trumped campaign, in component because the reports about his lucrative consulting occupational on behalf of pro-Russian Ukrainian politicians.

Still, Mr. Trump has actually seized ~ above emails released end the past several weeks indigenous Mrs. Clinton’s tenure as secretary of state, in i beg your pardon a grasp of donors are mentioned. That has assaulted her over an e-mail chain that proved Douglas J. Band, an adviser to Mr. Clinton, seeking come arrange a meeting between a an elderly American government official and Gilbert Chagoury, a Lebanese-Nigerian genuine estate developer that donated in between $1 million and also $5 million. Mr. Chagoury described through a spokesman the he had simply want to provide insights on poll in Lebanon.

Some emails and also other records defined donors seeking and also in some situations obtaining meetings with State department officials. None verified Mrs. Clinton making decisions in donate of any type of contributors, but her allies fear that additional emails could come out and also provide an ext fodder for Mr. Trump.

Craig Minassian, a spokesman for the foundation, claimed the decision to give up corporate and also foreign money had nothing to execute with the emails. The foundation will proceed to advanced money indigenous American individuals and charities.

“The only aspect is that we eliminate the tardy problems, if she wins the presidency,” that said, “and make sure that programs can proceed in some form for people who are being helped.”

But Tom Fitton, the president of judicial Watch, a conservative group that has actually sued to attain records indigenous Mrs. Clinton’s time in ~ the State Department, claimed that “the damage is done.”


“The problems of interest are actors in stone, and also it is something the the Clinton administration is walking to have to grapple with,” Mr. Fitton said. “It will actors a zero over your policies.”

And in an election year in which a bulk of american say they execute not to trust Mrs. Clinton, even some allies doubted why the structure had not reined in foreign donations sooner, or ended them immediately.


A Bloomberg poll in June confirmed that 72 percent of voters claimed it bothered them one of two people a lot or a little that the Clinton foundation took money indigenous foreign countries while Mrs. Clinton was secretary the state. In a CNN/ORC international Poll the very same month, 38 percent that voters said Mr. Clinton should fully step down from the foundation, when 60 percent said he should be able to continue working with the foundation if his wife became president. Mr. Clinton said Thursday he would certainly leave the foundation’s board if Mrs. Clinton won.

Edward G. Rendell, a former democratic governor of Pennsylvania, stated the structure should it is in disbanded if Mrs. Clinton wins, and also he included that it would make feeling for the charity to stop taking foreign donations immediately.


Chelsea Clinton and also Victor Pinchuk throughout her visit come Kiev, Ukraine, in 2012.Credit...Efram Lukatsky/Associated Press

“I think they’ll do the appropriate thing,” Mr. Rendell said, “and the best thing right here is, there is no question, that the an initial gentleman have nothing to execute with increasing money for the foundation.”

Mr. Minassian said ending foreign fund-raising prior to other resources of money might be found, and without discovering who will win the election, can needlessly gut program that assist provide, because that instance, H.I.V. Medication to children in Africa.


Begun in 1997, the foundation has raised approximately $2 billion and also is overseen by a plank that has Mr. Clinton and the couple’s daughter, Chelsea. Mrs. Clinton joined as soon as she left the State Department and stepped down in 2015 before beginning her campaign. Its job-related covers 180 countries, helping fund an ext than 3,500 projects.

Having a previous president in ~ the helm proved specifically productive, with foreign leaders and business people opening their doors — and also their wallets — come the preternaturally sociable Mr. Clinton.

Among the charity’s accomplishments: that is Clinton Health access Initiative — i m sorry is run by Ira C. Magaziner, that was a White residence aide involved in Mrs. Clinton’s failed effort to review the health care system in she husband’s first term — renegotiated the cost of H.I.V. Medicine to make them available to 11.5 million people. The foundation helped lug healthier meals to more than 31,000 institutions in the united States, and it has actually helped 105,000 farmers in east Africa increase their yields, according to the foundation’s tally.


In December 2008, shortly before Mrs. Clinton ended up being secretary of state, Mr. Clinton exit a list of more than 200,000 donors come defuse speculation around conflicts.

Soon after, Mrs. Clinton agreed to keep structure matters different from official business, including a pledge come “not get involved personally and also substantially in any particular matter that has a direct and predictable effect upon” the structure without a waiver. The Obama White residence had particularly disliked the gatherings of world leaders, academics and business people, dubbed the Clinton an international Initiative, the the structure was hold overseas. The foundation limited the conferences to residential locations when Mrs. Clinton to be secretary that state. On Thursday, Mr. Clinton claimed the collection in September in new York would certainly be the foundation’s last.

One the the attendees at this conferences speak to the stickiness of part donor relationships.

Victor Pinchuk, a stole magnate whose father-in-law, Leonid Kuchma, was president that Ukraine from 1994 come 2005, has actually directed in between $10 million and $25 million come the foundation. He has actually lent his private plane to the Clintons and traveled to Los Angeles in 2011 to to visit Mr. Clinton’s star-studded 65th date of birth celebration.

Between September 2011 and November 2012, Douglas E. Schoen, a former political consultant for Mr. Clinton, arranged about a dozen meetings v State room officials on instead of of or through Mr. Pinchuk to comment on the continuing political dilemm in Ukraine, follow to reports Mr. Schoen filed as a registered lobbyist.


“I had actually breakfast with Pinchuk. He will view you at the Brookings lunch,” Melanne Verveer, a Ukrainian-American then functioning for the State Department, composed in a June 2012 email to Mrs. Clinton.


On the Trail: The main of Aug. 14


11 Photos

View Slide show ›


Damon Winter/The new York Times

A formerly undisclosed email derived by citizen United, the conservative advocacy group, through public documents lawsuits shows the name of Mr. Pinchuk, defined as one of Ukraine’s “most effective businessmen,” among those on one eight-page list of influential civilization invited come a dinner party in ~ the Clintons’ home.

Earlier in 2012, Ambassador john F. Tefft created to Mrs. Clinton around a visit come Ukraine by Chelsea Clinton and her husband, Marc Mezvinsky, “at the invite of oligarch, Victor Pinchuk.” Mrs. Clinton replied, “As girlfriend know, hearing pretty things around your kids is as an excellent as it gets.”

In July 2013, the commerce Department started investigating complaints the Ukraine — and by expansion Mr. Pinchuk’s company, Interpipe — and eight other countries had illegally dumped a form of steel tube on the American market at artificially short prices.

A representative for Mr. Pinchuk stated the investigation had actually nothing to execute with the State Department, had actually started after ~ Mrs. Clinton’s tenure and also been exposed in July 2014. He included that at the very least 100 other civilization had to visit the dinner party in ~ Mrs. Clinton’s house and that she and also Mr. Pinchuk had talked briefly about democracy in Ukraine.

A deal including the revenue of American uranium holdings come a Russian state-owned enterprise was one more example of the structure intersecting through Mrs. Clinton’s official function in the Obama administration. She State department was among the agencies that signed turn off on the deal, which involved significant Clinton charity backers native Canada.


There to be no evidence that Mrs. Clinton had exerted affect over the deal, but the timing of the transaction and the donations raised questions around whether the donors had received favorable handling.

See more: Where Do Chip And Joanna Gaines Farmhouse Location, Chip And Joanna Gaines House Tour

Even if Mr. Clinton steps down, there might be staying complications about a potential president’s surname being affixed to an worldwide foundation. And also Chelsea Clinton, who is its vice chairwoman, would proceed her leadership role.

“It is very challenging to see how the organization called the Clinton foundation can proceed to exist during a Clinton presidency without the posing all sorts that consequences,” stated John Wonderlich, the interim executive director that the sunshine Foundation, a government watchdog group in Washington. “What lock announced only addresses the most egregious potential conflicts.”

Considering the scale and scope the the foundation, Mr. Wonderlich stated it was easy to “name a hundred different types of conflicts.”