President invoice Clinton took the podium ~ above October 18, 1994, v aspeech the reads choose a sigh of relief—the notice of a landmark atom agreement in between the unified States and North Korea. “This covenant is an excellent for the unified States, an excellent for our allies, and great for the security of the whole world,” he assured the nation. Dubbed the i agreeed Framework, it was designed to put the brakes on phibìc Korea’s nuclear program, and also it promised to placed an end to year of raising nuclear tension, including a near war, to a halt.

You are watching: Clinton nuclear deal with north korea

“This commitment represents the very first step on the roadway to a nuclear-free oriental Peninsula,” Clinton said. “It walk not count on trust.” In exchange because that North Korea finishing its nuclear tools program, the United says agreed to normalize relationships with the nation—and both i agree to seek “formal assurances” not to usage nukes against one another.

The agreement—forged against all odds in an setting of fear and also worry—seemed bulletproof. So why did the fail simply a few years later? The factors why are rooted in behind-the-scenes negotiations and also international mistrust.

North Korea had been preparing because that nuclear war since the Cold War, once the USSR started to train North korean scientists to build nuclear weapons. As component of the Communist bloc, phibìc Korea was very closely aligned v the USSR, and also Moscow listed the technology, training and also even geological surveys that aided North Korea locate regional deposits of graphite and uranium ore that can be offered to produce nuclear weapons.


A1992 file photo showing missiles marching in the North korean People’s forces’ 60th anniversary parade. (Credit: Jiji Press/KNS/AFP/Getty Images)

Despite its apparent commitment to emerging nuclear weapons, North oriental leader Kim Il Sung go ratify the contract on the Non-Proliferation the Nuclear weapons in 1985. The international treaty, which was designed to avoid the spread of nuclear weapons, had remained in force since 1970, however North Korea had actually lagged behind other countries like the unified States. Currently that north Korea to be on board, though, it likewise began mining uranium and producing plutonium—both crucial to the production of atom weapons—and producing nuclear reactors during the 1980s. Then, in 1989, the Soviet Union fell, leaving phibìc Korea significantly isolated.

“With the collapse of the Soviet Union, north Korea shed its main protector,” Georgetown university professor Keir LeibertoldVox’s Zack Beauchamp. “What go it have actually that can respond to conventional us power? The price is obvious: atom weapons.”

That exact same year, the U.S. Discovered Kim Il Sung’s hidden nuclear program using satellite imagery, and North Korea kept emerging weapons even afteragreeing with southern Korea not to check or manufacture nukes. Together a result, the global Atomic energy Agency, an autonomous nuclear oversight organization that reports directly to the unified Nations, asked to conduct inspections of North korean nuclear web page in 1992 and 1993. North Korea refused, and also threatened to ago out the the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

This represented a double crisis for then-President Clinton. Republicans in conference pressured him not to negotiate with North Korea, yet the global community and also Democrats suggested that engagement was the just solution. Meanwhile, phibìc Korea escalated the rhetoric,telling the United claims that phibìc Korea would turn Seoul right into “a sea of flames” if the U.S. Pursued sanctions with the unified Nations.


Former north Korea president Kim Il Sung sitting alongside former U.S. Chairman Jimmy Carter in June 1994, simply weeks before Kim’s death. (Credit: Korean central News Agency/AP Photo)

The U.S. Considered military intervention, but also sent Jimmy Carter to Pyongyang to accomplish with Kim Il Sung. Carter convinced Kim to begin nuclear talks—but the day negotiations were an alleged to begin, Kim died. He was succeeded by his son, Kim Jong Il, the very man who established the many controversial nuclear complex in phibìc Korea, a facility in Yongbyon.

Things looked grim, but Clinton came to be increasingly encouraged that direct negotiations were the only way. However, American negotiators wondered about from the start that diplomacy would work. “The initial contacts were to test the proposition that we could address their security pertains to by gaining them to provide up your nuclear weapons,” Robert Gallucci, the chef negotiator,toldBeyond Parallel in a 2016 interview. “It was no so lot of a conviction top top anybody’s part…It was probably true, and worth testing.”

For 16 months, Gallucci and his team performed intense negotiations with North Korea. The countries locked horns on what it would take for North Korea to stop creating nukes. Finally, they concerned an agreement—the agreed Framework.

Just 4 pages long, theagreement stated that phibìc Korea would certainly shut under its main nuclear reactor in Yongbyon, abandon two others, and also seal fuel that could potentially be offered to develop a nuclear weapon. In exchange, the U.S. Would carry out oil to comprise for the fuel lost from the dismantled plants and also would construct two new “light fuel” plants from which it would certainly be harder come extract atom materials. If north Korea did shot to obtain fuel out of the new plants, it would beeasy for nuclear watchdogs come identify—and hard to hide. In addition, the agreement promised the the U.S. Would certainly lift financial sanctions and also its diplomatic freeze on phibìc Korea and also agree the it would certainly not use nuclear tools of its very own on phibìc Korea.


President bill Clinton watch on as Assistant Secretary that State Robert Gallucci meets reporters in the White residence briefing room, October 18, 1994. The president announced the North Korea i agree to frozen its existing nuclear program and also accept international inspection of all its atom facilities. (Credit: Marcy Nighswander/Getty Images)

See more: Cashing In Savings Bonds Tax Implications, Series Ee/E Savings Bonds Tax Considerations

On the surface, that looked like the U.S. To be offering huge concessions to north Korea in exchange for few assurances. Yet behind the scenes, the Clinton administrationthought the North Korea was on the verge of collapse and also likely wouldn’t critical long enough for the U.S. To build the agreed-upon reactors. In phibìc Korea, the agreement wasn’t bring away seriously. Isolated, impoverished and also headed by a leader who thought nuclear power would offer the nation power on the global stage, phibìc Korea had tiny motivation to offer up the program.

Clinton knew the commitment would be hugely controversial—so that structured it in a way that guarantee it wouldn’t have to be validated by the Senate. Republicans to be infuriated. And shortly after ~ the covenant was signed, the republic won manage of Congress. They grilled Gallucci. “It was pretty harsh,” hetold PBS in 2003. “We walk not get ticker ice cream parades, together it turned out.” conference made it clear the they would not agree come actually money the implementation that the task or sanction formal peace agreements between the two countries.

Meanwhile, phibìc Korea continued producing uranium. Kim Jong Il, it turned out, had actually used potential nukes as a bargaining chip—even despite he had actually no intention of protecting against the program. In spite of promisinginitial results, north Korea began flouting the agreement an ext and more. Phibìc Korea ignored warnings the the commitment was in jeopardy and also soon knowledge agencies realized it own much an ext advanced nuclear technology than the U.S. Had actually suspected.

At very first it seemed favor George W. Bush, who took office in 2001, might proceed Clinton-era diplomatic plans toward phibìc Korea. However then things fell apart. Bush’s diplomats stopped sending fuel shipments; north Korea complained bitterly that the promised nuclear reactors had actually never been built. And also when the September 11 terrorist assaults happened, it pushed American diplomacy in other directions—and bush mentioned phibìc Korea as among the three countries in his “Axis of Evil” State of the Union decided in 2002.

Soon, relations between the two nations were open minded tense, if no hostile. North Korea dropped out of the nuclear Non-Proliferation treaty in 2003. Through 2006, the had performed its an initial nuclear test—an underground distribution that may have been a fizzle, or not successful explosion. And though bill Clinton himselfheaded to phibìc Korea to efficiently negotiate the relax of 2 American hostages in 2009, that was too late come halt phibìc Korea’s march towards nukes.

Though the unified States proceeds to shot to look for solutions to north Korea’s potential nukes, including the potential the talks between President Donald Trump and also Kim Jong Un, Clinton’s vision the an finish to nuclear proliferation top top the korean Peninsula currently seems an ext like a mirage.