The 3rd Amendment addressed colonists’ grievances with British soldiers, and has due to the fact that played only a small duty in legit cases.

You are watching: Court cases involving the 3rd amendment


The very first and second Amendments obtain a most attention, however the third rarely come up in court. That reads, in full: “No Soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any type of house, without the consent of the Owner, nor over time of war, yet in a way to be prescribed by law.”


The U.S. Validated it in response to a an extremely specific set of circumstances in the so late 18th century involving the brothers military. Even so, there are a few 20th and 21st century legal instances in i beg your pardon courts have mentioned or thought about the amendment.

The 3rd Amendment to be in solution to brothers Quartering Acts

Between 1754 and 1763, the British realm sent 10s of hundreds of soldiers to its American colonies to struggle the French and Indian battle for regulate of the Ohio flow valley. Afterward, many of these soldiers ongoing to live together a standing army in the 13 colonies. In 1765, the British conference passed a Quartering action requiring the swarms to feed and also house this soldiers.


“The colonists were to administer barracks because that the soldiers, and if castle were not available, the troops to be to be billeted in inns, stables, and alehouses,” to write Gordon S. Wood, a professor of background emeritus in ~ Brown University, for the nationwide Constitution Center. “f these to be insufficient, the governors and also councils of the districts were authorized to usage uninhabited houses, barns, and other structures to lodge the soldiers.”

This act was unpopular in the colonies, specifically after the 1770 Boston Massacre in i m sorry British troops fired top top a crowd and also killed 5 people. In an answer to farming unrest in the colonies, Parliament introduced an even much more invasive Quartering action in 1774 as part of the so-called “Intolerable” or “Coercive Acts.” 


READ MORE: 7 events That furious Colonists and also Led to the American Revolution

This quartering was amongst the grievances cutting board Jefferson provided in the declaration of Independence. Specifically, the accused King George III of maintaining “among us, in times of Peace, standing Armies, there is no the Consent or of our Legislatures,” and also “quartering huge Bodies of armed Troops amongst us.”


*

The an initial Continental conference met in Carpenter's Hall, Philadelphia to specify American rights and organize a setup of resistance come the Coercive Acts imposed by the british Parliament.

See more: Cynthia Nixon Sex In The City

MPI/Getty Images


After the American Revolution, the constitutional framers disputed whether the United states should also have a was standing army. The federalists won that debate, however James Madison created the third Amendment for the bill of legal rights to guarantee the the federal government couldn’t force local governments, businesses and also citizens to house U.S. Soldiers.

“Ultimately, the founders decided that a standing army was a essential evil, but that the role of soldiers would be just to dispel foreign threats, no to enforce laws versus American citizens,” writes reporter Radley Balko for the American Bar combination Journal. Balko adds, “For the first 50 year or so after ratification the the Constitution, military troops to be rarely, if ever, provided for routine law enforcement. But, end time, that would change.”