Analysis: If there is noþeles to be gleaned indigenous the reaction come the famous video, it is that most Americans live in bubbles filled by civilization like them.

You are watching: Covington catholic white male entitlement high school


When for free looked at the videos shot near the Lincoln Memorial critical Friday, they witnessed a smirking, entitled child of likely Donald trump card voters. Below was a Catholic institution boy who appeared to gain a silent but disrespectful faceoff with an older indigenous American man and also his drum, while the boy’s white classmates tomahawk chopped and also jeered.

When conservative looked at the exact same videos they witnessed a arsenal of kids waiting because that a bus near the memorial after ~ participating in the March because that Life. The boys faced verbal goading by black Israelites and also were confronted by an unusual native American guy with a drum however stayed confident by doing soul cheers. The Covington Catholic High School kids were the lambs, and the others to be wolves circling them.

In the mainly since, it’s come to be clear that at the very least some of each of those perspectives is true, yet virtually no one’s mind has been changed about what actually happened and also what every one of it means.

“It appears everyone wants a basic story,” claimed Matt Motyl, a political psychologist and also assistant professor in ~ the university of Illinois at Chicago. Motyl, who is likewise a research other at new York University, research studies why human being have a hard time talking around hot-button problems without problem or room reticent to interact with those that contradict the views they currently hold.


For every the distinct and practically theatrical facets of the event on the nationwide Mall, that the reaction to the incident, and the reaction to that reaction, that appeared to compel many Americans to pick a side. If there is anything like a fact to it is in gleaned indigenous the whole mess, it is that in this deeply separated America, most human being live, work, learn, worship, protest and also play within of bubbles filled by civilization much favor them. That dynamic contributes come clashes once the balloon collide, resulting in viral moment of i m sorry no one need to be proud and raising tensions approximately unstoppable demographic and social change.

We all tend to like and also hold in higher esteem people who are favor us, human being in our “group.” In his research, Motyl uses a long-standing social scientific research tool that can best be described as the warmth and regard scale, a sort of society thermometer. It ranges from a cold 0 to a really warm 100. That study has shown that for much of the critical century, people, top top average, related to hypothetical human being who common their political see somewhere approximately an 80 and those who did no somewhere around 60, a figure not much from a neutral 50. But since the 1990s, miscellaneous dramatic has actually taken shape: People’s mean esteem for those that share your views has actually grown to approximately 90, if mistrust and also “coldness” toward those who perform not have slipped come an typical of 10.

Put an additional way, as soon as the initial video clip emerged showing a team of white teenage boys, countless of castle clad in make America an excellent Again hats and some of them executing tomahawk chops, showing up to challenge off v an older indigenous American — all while standing near a monument devoted to Lincoln, the emancipator — America reacted. In some cases, civilization picked the details the affirmed and also aligned through the conversations already happening inside your bubbles and discarded the rest. And, because those top top the other side of the political spectrum are no longer regarded as merely different yet potentially evil or disreputable, numerous attributed the worst possible motives come those providing differing interpretations.

To numerous people, those MAGA hats visible in the video clip clips established at least some that those students together willing personalities in one ongoing culture war, said Robert Jones, founding CEO of the Public religious beliefs Research Institute and author the the book “The finish of White Christian America.”

The culture war started long before the young guys of Covington Catholic to be born.

Starting in the 1960s, countless white Christian conservative left the autonomous Party because that the Republican camp in the contrary to widening civil legal rights to afri Americans. Castle rejected the race mingling and other social transforms that would certainly follow.

And by the 1990s, when opposition to abortion, happy rights and also later gay marriage ranked amongst the chief political comes to of conservative white Christians, right-leaning Catholics began to sign up with this fold.

At the time, white Christians represented a true majority. As recently as 2008, white christians — Catholics and Protestants — consisted of 54 percent that the country. Today, that number is 42 percent.

“Demographic change is miscellaneous you typically talk about in terms of a generation or two,” Jones said. “Demographic adjust that quick can set off extreme reactions, intense emotions.” Jones likened this emotions come the step of grieving defined by psychologist Elisabeth Kübler-Ross. She model contains five stages: denial, anger, bargaining, depression and also acceptance. Human being do not always make direct or sustained progress.

“I’d say, right now, the conservative white Christian political motion moves ago and forth in between denial and anger,” Jones said. “In Trump and also the decision to earlier a leader doing not have in the very character the moral bulk always put ahead that everything, they’ve gone into into a type of bargaining.”

That background has loomed in the backdrop together the parental of the Covington students have said the their youngsters are the bias-free progeny of religious families trying to raise your sons through values. End the course of the week, they’ve likewise become the topics of intense national scrutiny, your churches, diocese and school topic to threats and also shutdowns.

See more: City Of West Palm Beach Police Department, West Palm Beach Pd

They’ve safeguarded their children against accusations the they’re the form of entitled, wild young white American males free to operate with impunity, suggesting that they room the victims here.

“Everyone wants their next to it is in good, to it is in right, and the various other to be plainly bad,” Motyl said. “But due to the fact that we don’t watch the same news, we don’t review the very same information and also we nothing talk lot to people with other perspectives, it’s as if we space actually living in different human beings where no one has actually really grasped the truth.”