Comprehensive immigration reform has actually eluded Congress because that years, moving controversial policy decisions right into the executive and judicial branches of government.

You are watching: Current immigration issues in the us

Migrants wait in heat to seek asylum after illegal entering the United claims in Hidalgo, Texas. Loren Elliott/Reuters
Immigrants have long consisted of a far-reaching portion the the U.S. Population. In 2019, lock comprised virtually 14 percent.Congress has actually failed to agree on exactly how to deal with immigration challenges, leavingmany policy questions as much as the courts and executive branch.President Joe Biden has reversed plenty of of previous President Donald Trump’s restrictivepolicies, also as he has struggled v a historical influx that migrants.


Immigration has been a touchstone the the U.S. Political dispute for decades, together policymakers have weighed economic, security, and also humanitarian concerns. Congress has been can not to reach an covenant on comprehensive immigration reform for years, efficiently moving some major policy decisions into the executive and judicial branches that government and fueling controversy in the halls of state and also municipal governments.

Former president Donald Trump put the issues ago at the center of public controversy with his unprecedented initiatives to curb immigration and also reshape asylum policy. Chairman Joe Biden pledged to reverse Trump’s actions and reform the system, but the recurring COVID-19 pandemic and also a an excellent influx of migrants have facility his plans.

What is the immigrant populace in the unified States?

More on:


United states

Immigration and Migration

Border and also Port security

Donald trumped

Immigrants comprised virtually 14 percent that the U.S. Population, or nearly 45 million civilization out the a total of about 328 million in 2019, follow to the Census Bureau. Together, immigrants and also their U.S.-born children make up about 26 percent of U.S. Inhabitants.

Daily News Brief
A an introduction of worldwide news advancements with analysis delivered to your inbox each morning. Most weekdays.
Email address
">View all newsletters >

The re-publishing of the population that is foreign-born has actually steadily risen due to the fact that 1970, as soon as there to be fewer 보다 ten million immigrant in the unified States. However there are proportionally fewer immigrants this day than in 1890, when foreign-born inhabitants comprised almost 15 percent of the population. 

As of 2018, Mexico was the most typical country of origin for U.S. Immigrants, constituting 25 percent the the immigrant population. However, Asia was the top region of origin, v 28 percent of immigrants born there.

More From our Experts
James M. Lindsay
Thanking America"s Veterans
Edward Alden
Why space Haitian Migrants collection at the U.S. Border?
Caroline Bettinger-Lopez
Constitutionalizing Equality: The Equal civil liberties Amendment as a Catalyst for adjust

Undocumented immigration. The undocumented population is estimated to be around eleven million people and has leveled turn off due to the fact that its peak before the 2008 financial crisis, i beg your pardon led part to return to their residence countries and also discouraged others from coming to the joined States. In July 2021, Customs and Border protection (CBP) reported an ext than 212,000 to meet with civilization trying to overcome the southerly border, the highest monthly figure in 2 decades.

Roughly two-thirds that undocumented immigrants have actually lived in the United says for much more than a decade, and many are the parental of U.S.-born children. Till 2013, almost every one of those do the efforts to cross the U.S.-Mexico border were Mexican citizens and most were individuals seeking work; since then, central Americans have consisted of an increasingly large share, reaching 81 percent in 2019. Generally, they space coming not for work but to make asylum claims, and many that them are unaccompanied children. Some of these immigrant have various legal civil liberties from mexican nationals in the united States: under a 2008 anti–human smuggling law, unaccompanied minors from noncontiguous countries have a best to a hearing prior to being deported to their residence countries. The spike in main American migration has strained the U.S. Immigration system, with an ext than 1.2 million situations pending in immigration courts.

More on:


United states

Immigration and Migration

Border and Port protection

Donald trumped

Though numerous of the policies that aim to alleviate unlawful immigration focus on enforcement in ~ the border, individuals who arrive in the United claims legally and also overstay their visas make up a far-ranging portion the the undocumented population. A center for Migration researches report uncovered that, in 2010–2018, individuals who overstayed your visas much outnumbered those who arrived by cross the border illegally.

Legal immigration. The United claims granted around one million individuals legal long-term residency in fiscal year 2019, which is approximately on par with most years because the at an early stage 1990s. An ext than two-thirds that them were admitted ~ above the basis of family members reunification. Various other categories included: employment-based choices (14 percent), refugees (8 percent), diversity (4 percent), and asylees (3 percent). In so late 2020, virtually four million applicants to be on the State Department’s waiting list because that family- and employer-related immigrant visas.

Hundreds that thousands of foreign nationals work-related legally in the United claims under various varieties of nonimmigrant visas. In budget year 2020, the United states granted close to 125,000 vi for high-skilled workers, well-known as H1B visas, and more than 275,000 vi for momentary workers in agriculture and other industries. H1B visas are capped in ~ 85,000 per year, v exceptions for particular fields.

Immigrants comprised 17 percent the the U.S. Civilian labor force in 2020, according to the bureau of job Statistics. Contrasted to those born in the unified States, greater shares the immigrants worked in service fields (20.6 percent of all foreign-born people); production, transportation, and also material relocating (15.2 percent); and also natural resources, construction, and also maintenance (13.6 percent). A 2017 Pew Research facility study projected that, there is no immigrants, the U.S. Workforce would decline by virtually ten million world by 2035.

How execute Americans feel around immigration?

A 2020 Gallup poll found that 77 percent of american surveyed thought about immigration a good thing for the united States, the highest possible level in 2 decades. In ~ the very same time, however, majorities felt that illegal immigration was a significant threat and that immigration should be maintained at the same level or decreased.

According to a separate poll performed by Vox and also Data for development the complying with year, 69 percent of voters surveyed—including a majority of Republicans—supported a course to citizenship for undocumented immigrants if they meet certain requirements. A better share (72 percent) supported citizenship for immigrants brought to the joined States when they were minors, who are regularly referred to as Dreamers.

How has actually Congress tried to resolve the issue?

The last push for a major immigration overhaul came in 2013, adhering to a te in which conference debated numerous immigration reforms, some considered comprehensive, rather piecemeal. (Comprehensive immigrant reform refers to omnibus law that make the efforts to resolve the adhering to issues: need for high- and low-skilled labor, the legal standing of the millions of undocumented immigrant living in the country, border security, and interior enforcement.) The last considerable legislation to survive Congress to be under chairman Ronald Reagan in 1986; it gave legal elegance to some 3 million undocumented residents. In 2007, chairman George W. Shrub worked through congressional democracy to with a damage on a brand-new comprehensive bill, but it ultimately failed come win sufficient support.

President Barack Obama pressed difficult for a an extensive bill that would certainly pair a path to legalization because that undocumented residents with stronger border protection provisions. The Democrat-led Senate happen this law in 2013, but the bill stalled in the Republican-controlled residence of Representatives. Both Trump and also Biden proposed considerable reforms, but Congress has not considered either.

What to be the Obama administration’s approach?

With law thwarted, Obama took several executive actions to administer temporary legitimate protections because that undocumented immigrants. In 2012, his administration began a program well-known as Deferred activity for Childhood arrivals (DACA), which available renewable, two-year deportation deferrals and work patent to undocumented immigrant who had arrived in the United states as children and also had no criminal records. 

Obama characterized the relocate as a “stopgap measure” and urged congress to pass the DREAM Act, legislation very first introduced in 2001 the would have actually benefited plenty of of the same people. Due to the fact that then, much more than eight hundreds thousand people have participated in the program, and also 1.7 million an ext are eligible. Obama attempted come extend similar benefits to undocumented parental of U.S. Citizens and permanent citizens in a program recognized as Deferred activity for parents of american (DAPA), yet the can be fried Court efficiently killed the routine in 2016.

In 2014, Obama likewise grappled v a surging of much more than sixty thousand unaccompanied minors in ~ the southern border, mainly from main America. His administration directed $750 million in assist to the region to improve problems there. Meanwhile, the administration faced criticism because that its enforcement policies, consisting of detaining kids in poor conditions and also overseeing the deportation of much more people—more than 3 million—than either the invoice Clinton or George W. Bush administrations had.

What was the trumped administration’s approach?

Immigration was a signature issue for Trump and a perpetual resource of debate during his term. Blaming previous administrations for failing come secure the southerly border, he promoted for high solution reducing both legal and illegal immigration. That took plenty of steps, plenty of through executive, management action, come reshape asylum, deportation, and also border policy. 

Border security and also enforcement. Trumped vowed to increase the wall along the U.S.-Mexico border, i m sorry he asserted would protect against drugs and gangs from entering the country. The was not successful in securing funding from Congress, bring about a federal government shutdown in 2019 and also Trump to ultimately declare a nationwide emergency, which permitted him to draw away funds to the wall. 

Trump additionally ratcheted increase previous administrations’ deterrence efforts. He implemented a zero-tolerance policy, under which authorities arrested and also prosecuted everyone recorded crossing the southern border there is no authorization. This brought about thousands of family separations, because by law kids must be held apart from parents dealing with criminal prosecution. (Presidents Bush and Obama likewise faced criticism for boy detention, however they did not make separations a matter of policy.)

trump sought to sharply mitigate the number of refugees and also other immigrants granted legit entry.
Other enforcement measures included ordering an increase in border personnel; sending out thousands of active-duty troops come the border; threatening Mexico through tariffs if that did not boost its very own border enforcement; and also attempting to reduced federal resources to so-called sanctuary cities, or jurisdictions the refuse to enforce federal immigration directives.

DACA. Trump sought to end DACA, calling that unconstitutional. The move spurred multiple legal obstacles and, in June 2020, the can be fried Court clogged Trump’s plan. A December 2020 federal court ruling forced the Trump management to resume accepting new applicants.

Travel bans and refugee cap. Trump sought come sharply minimize the number of refugees and other immigrant granted legitimate entry. In 2017, the instituted a ban on immigrant or travel from number of Muslim-majority countries. The original order was rejected by the courts, but the supreme Court upheld a more minimal version. Trump also lowered the cap on the number of refugees the United says accepts every year to less than eighteen thousand, down from around eighty thousand prior to he take it office. Additionally, he finished temporary safeguarded status (TPS)—a routine that enables migrants from particular crisis-stricken countries to live in the United says for a minimal period—for numerous countries.

Asylum policy. Trumped implemented brand-new restrictions ~ above asylum seekers. In 2018, the administration began “metering” asylum applications, or just accepting a limited number every day. The following year, it launched the Migrant defense Protocols (MPP), also known as stay in Mexico, which forced asylum seekers to remain in Mexico if their situations were pending. In ~ the same time, the sought “safe 3rd country” agreements with Guatemala, Mexico, Panama, and others, which would have allowed U.S. Authorities come send asylum seekers who traveled v those countries ago there. Just the commitment with Guatemala to be implemented prior to that nation suspended that in 2020. 

Comprehensive reform effort. Prefer his prompt predecessors, trump proposed a wide immigration reform. His would have produced a merit-based device to replace the present one, which prioritizes family members reunification. It likewise included expansion of the border wall surface and an employment verification system known as E-Verify however did not deal with the condition of present undocumented residents.

How has actually the pandemic altered immigration policy?

The Trump administration further minimal immigration amid the COVID-19 pandemic by: curbing take trip to the unified States, successfully halting asylum procedures, transforming away most migrants in ~ the U.S.-Mexico border, and suspending the processing of numerous foreign worker visas and green cards. 

The management framed these alters as vital to limit the virus’s spread and protect American jobs, yet critics accused trump of using the public health crisis to more his anti-immigration agenda. Some argued that the detention and deportation the migrants during the pandemic fueled the virus’s spread. 

Despite his stated goal of reversing Trump’s border policies, Biden has maintained most pandemic-related restrictions, including limits on nonessential entry into the country. Many notably, he has kept in place a pandemic-related public health and wellness order that permits for prompt expulsion of arrest migrants, though he has exempted unaccompanied children and also some adults. 

What is the Biden administration’s approach?

Biden campaigned ~ above overturning almost every one of Trump’s immigrant policies. In its first months, his administration has bring away dozens of actions, yet his attempts to revolutionary the system have actually collided with a dramatic rise in migration to the southerly border.

Biden’s measures to drown Trump-era plans have consisted of reducing immigration enforcement within the unified States, finishing the travel bans, lifting the suspension of eco-friendly card processing, and halting construction of the wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. His administration has also expanded TPS protections, canceled safe third country agreements, and raised the refugee lid to 62,500 after initially maintaining the limit enforced under Trump. That has additionally launched efforts to rate the reunification the migrant families, consisting of by reinstating the central American Minors (CAM) program, i m sorry reunites youngsters in the northern Triangle through parents in the joined States.

However, Biden has faced roadblocks. His discontinuation of continue to be in Mexico was tested by numerous states and then clogged by the can be fried Court. A commonwealth judge stopped DACA, putting that program’s future in doubt. Meanwhile, a historical influx that migrants in ~ the southerly border threatens to destabilize Biden’s efforts further: ~ a pandemic-related drop, border apprehensions spiked to nearly two hundreds thousand in July 2021, the highest level in much more than twenty years. Tens of hundreds of migrants, plenty of of them children, are detained in emergency facilities. The administration has seek to address underlying causes of the crisis, promising $4 exchange rate in brand-new aid to central American countries, but at the very same time has issued stern warnings to would-be migrants to no make the journey.

Biden sent out to congress his own an extensive immigration bill, which would develop a course to citizenship because that undocumented immigrants, broaden visa and green map availability, broaden asylum eligibility, and an increase border security spending. However, professionals say it will certainly be challenging for the proposal come win sufficient Republican support. 

How are state and also local authorities taking care of these issues?

States differ widely in how they act unauthorized immigrants. Part states, such as California, enable undocumented immigrants to apply for drivers’ licenses, receive in-state tuition at universities, and obtain other benefits. At the other end of the spectrum, states such as Arizona have actually passed legislations permitting police come question world they doubt of being unauthorized about their immigrant status.

The federal federal government is typically responsible for enforcing immigration laws, but it delegates part immigration-related duties come state and local law enforcement. However, the level to which neighborhood officials room obliged come cooperate with federal authorities is a topic of intense debate. Together of 2019, nearly one-quarter of U.S. Counties limit their participation with ICE, according to the Immigrant Legal source Center.

The degree to which regional officials room obliged come cooperate v federal authorities is a topic of intense debate.

President trump decried this sanctuary jurisdictions and reinstated a controversial Obama-era program known as secure Communities, in i beg your pardon the FBI shares fingerprints that suspects gathered by state and local law enforcement with federal immigrant authorities. Under the program, state and local agencies additionally hand over people presumed to it is in in the nation illegally. Biden terminated the regime shortly after acquisition office. 

A selection of court rulings throughout the trumped era boosted pressure top top states. In 2018, the righteousness Department introduced a lawsuit versus California over sanctuary jurisdictions, i beg your pardon was eventually dismissed through the can be fried Court. That filed similar suits against new Jersey and also Washington and also a federal court rule in 2020 the the Trump management could withhold federal capital from sanctuary jurisdictions, including new York City. Under Biden, the justice Department has actually reversed this stance, top the can be fried Court come dismiss numerous pending cases.

See more: Day Care Or Daycare Ap Style

Trump’s border security plans prompted differing regional reactions. After ~ Trump referred to as on says to deploy national Guard contingents to the southerly border, several governors refused. Other governors, consisting of Texas’s Greg Abbot, adopted Trump’s views and also have vowed to continue work to broaden the border wall.