This post was featured in One great Story, New York’s analysis recommendation newsletter. Sign up here to obtain it nightly.

You are watching: Daniel lewis lee death row inmate


*

*

This post was featured in One good Story, New York’s analysis recommendation newsletter. Sign up here to obtain it nightly.


federal prison in Terre Haute, Indiana. Photo: TANNEN MAURY/EPA-EFE/Shutterstoc/TANNEN MAURY/EPA-EFE/Shutterstoc

“We owe it to the victims and also their households to lug forward the sentence imposed by ours justice system,” william Barr said last July, announcing that his justice Department would resume executing commonwealth death-row prisoners for the an initial time because 2003. But when officials eliminated Daniel Lewis Lee ~ above Tuesday, it was usual knowledge that several of his victims’ family members members wanted his life spared. It no matter. Lee’s death was a spectacle for the government’s benefit, no theirs.

Yesterday, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 the the office of Prisons could proceed with Lee’s execution. The decision i rejected an injunction issued on Monday by a ar court referee in Washington, D.C. Judge Tanya Chutkan ruled the the constitutionality the the planned technique of fatality — lethal injection using the medicine pentobarbital — had not been completely litigated, according to the new York Times. It was the second such legit hurdle cleared by the DOJ in the past week. The first was chose on Sunday by the U.S. Court the Appeals of the saturday Circuit. Some of Lee’s victims’ family members had sued the department because that requiring castle to threat coronavirus epidemic if they wished to take trip to Indiana to see his execution; they were originally granted a delay, however the appeals court reversed it.

Lee was sentenced to death in 1999. 3 years earlier, he’d accompanied Chevie Kehoe — the founder that a white-supremacist anti-government militia called the Aryan People’s Republic — to the house of william Mueller, a weapons dealer, exterior of Tilly, Arkansas. The pair was trying to find guns, ammunition, and also cash to steal; after ~ collecting every three, the two men incapacitated Mueller, his wife Nancy Mueller, and her 8-year-old daughter, sarah Elizabeth Powell, climate knocked lock unconscious, duct-taped plastic bags over their heads for this reason they’d suffocate, and weighed your bodies down through rocks before tossing them right into a swamp.

For Lee, the horrific killing capped turn off a life significant by abuse, mental health and wellness struggles, and also time invested locked up in youth detention centers. He’d been recruited by Kehoe to sign up with his militia and remained his subordinate — the “faithful dog” come Kehoe’s “ringleader,” together one judge, a prosecutor, and members that Kehoe’s family identified the men’s dynamic. According to the Times, Kehoe’s mother and brother testified the he’d personally eliminated 8-year-old Sarah because Lee lacked the stomach for it. Most evidence pointed come Kehoe’s primary function in planning, initiating, and also carrying out the crime, which appeared bound come condemn Lee to a equivalent fate — life in prison — or possibly something less. The prosecution team definitely thought so; that made little sense to pursue the fatality penalty because that Lee as soon as Kehoe had gotten life, they thought. The victims’ family members members agreed. But Justice department officials overruled them, claiming that Lee was as well dangerous even for prison. The DOJ insisted that the prosecutors seek funding punishment, and also a jury obliged. The decision haunts many of those connected to this day.

From the Times:

lead prosecutor in the trial, former Assistant United claims Attorney Dan Stripling, wrote in a 2014 letter to Eric H. Holder Jr., that was climate the lawyer general, that though he believed in resources punishment, he to be disturbed by the randomness the its imposition. Mr. Lee’s death sentence, that wrote, “perfectly illustrates this uncertain randomness.”

The commonwealth judge who looked after the psychological — G. Thomas Eisele, a Nixon appointee come the bench who passed away two years earlier — wrote in a 2015 letter to Mr. Holder the he had second-guessed his decisions ever before since and also was left “with the firm conviction the justice to be not served in this specific case, solely with regard come the sentence of death imposed on Daniel Lewis Lee.”

These misgivings to be echoed by number of of the victims’ household members. Nancy Mueller’s sister, Kimma Gurel, and also niece, Monica Veillette, both oppose capital punishment because that Lee. “It made no sense,” Gurel said of the different sentences between Lee and Kehoe, follow to the Times. Veillette has similarly advocated for his sentence to it is in commuted. Nancy Mueller’s mother, Earlene Branch Peterson, has taken a much more circuitous path to the exact same conclusion; she initially wanted both men killed, but years that prayer, counseling, and Bible study convinced her otherwise. “I can’t see how executing Daniel Lee will certainly honor my daughter in any way,” Peterson, a conservative trump supporter, claimed in a short documentary released critical year through the equal Justice Initiative, a funding defense and also legal advocacy organization based in Alabama. “The government ain’t act this because that me, ’cause I would say no.”

There’s tiny uniformity in exactly how victims to the the fate of your loved ones’ killers. Also in this certain case, yes divergence; Scott Mueller, son of the deceased wilhelm Mueller, has said the he doesn’t treatment if Lee dies or not. But Barr’s insurance claim that he’s repaying a blame to victims’ family members by resuming federal executions has actually been widely refuted. In enhancement to the the opposite of Nancy Mueller’s family, at least 175 civilization whose loved ones have been slain created to Barr and also President Trump last year, imploring them not to recommence killing fatality row prisoners. (The federal fatality penalty has been under casual moratorium because that 17 years.) their cries strengthened long-standing arguments that resources punishment is a ethical atrocity. Yes no evidence that it deters crime; it’s applied with racialism asymmetry the affects Black people disproportionately; and also it’s alarmingly error-prone — at the very least 165 human being who to be sentenced to death due to the fact that 1973 have since been proven innocent; a 2014 examine from the national Academy of Sciences estimated that, in ~ the rate things were going, 4.1 percent of people on death row would ultimately be exonerated. It’s additionally increasingly unpopular. In November, a Gallup poll uncovered that 60 percent of Americans choose life imprisonment for people convicted of killing — a dramatic come back from 2014, when simply 45 percent of people felt the exact same way.

But perhaps an ext than anything, Lee’s instance demonstrates the unnerving capriciousness the the whole enterprise. By most accounts and several measures, he was much less culpable 보다 his accomplice. Yet he’s the one who gained executed. Earlene Peterson, Nancy Mueller’s mother, has actually as theory as to why. Kehoe was charismatic and clean-cut, “like a young businessman,” Peterson said the Times — whereas Lee was the snapshot of menace: remote in one eye native a fight, his neck covered in swastika tattoos. Beyond that, the precise calculus provided to identify their disparate fates is anyone’s guess, however likelihoods abound. The political fads of the “tough top top crime” 1990s weren’t known for encouraging mercy or subtlety; the perpetrator of a vicious murder that looked the part would’ve been a organic target because that the prevailing bloodlust of the era. The rationales governing today’s decisions seem even much easier to surmise. Trump’s strategy because that retaining power has hinged foremost on amazing his base. That ran for president on assures to reclaim “law and order” and also Republicans are generally pro-execution, making the reconstruction of the federal fatality penalty a herbal political calculation.

See more: Carowinds Amusement Park Charlotte North Carolina & South Carolina

However one ideologies it, the decision to death Lee derives indigenous a rather nebulous and also inconsistent set of considerations, the dominant share that which seem politically urged on the component of federal officials, past and also present. It’s currently been solved in a manner befitting funding punishment chin — with cruel finality and abiding disinterest in the people who’ve to be harmed most directly, various other than what is politically beneficial to the executioners. Lee was strapped to a gurney for four hours awaiting his fate top top Tuesday morning, according to the Times. That looked around the chamber together the lethal substance was injected into his veins. He began breathing heavily, then went still. “ lips turned blue, and also his fingers came to be ashy,” write reporter Hailey Fuchs. He was dead by 8:07 a.m. — a casualty much less of justice than of political and administrative whim.