You are watching: Did any democrats vote to impeach clinton
WASHINGTON—A generation ago, the Senate considered a question that had actually not been posed in 131 years: whether to remove a president from office. Just twenty years later, the fraught inquiry is before senators again.
There are an essential differences between this psychological of the impeached chairman Trump and also that of invoice Clinton. In 1999, a Republican-controlled conference moved against a democratic president and Democrats decried Republicans’ calls because that witnesses. Now the duties are switched. Two decades ago, both parties in the Senate worked to craft a bipartisan procedure that would certainly be watched by Americans together fair and credible. That does not show up to be happening today.
A Democratic-led residence is battling not only the Republican president, but likewise the Republicans that run the Senate, with no signs of bipartisan covenant on any type of of the major disputes. And both political parties have struck the impartiality that the other, and questioned its procedures.
Many space looking come the 1999 impeachment trial as a model, v each next often focusing on the facets that finest fit their positions today.
Here’s a reminder of how that attempt unfolded.
Dec. 19, 1998: At the peak of an exceptionally divisive confrontation between Republicans and Democrats, the home approves two short articles of impeachment accusing Clinton of lied under oath and also obstructing justice in the investigation of his relationship with former White residence intern Monica S. Lewinsky. It likewise designates home managers and also notifies the Senate the its actions. (In contrast, house Speaker Nancy Pelosi waited number of weeks to name the residence managers and also forward the 2 articles versus Trump to the Senate.)
Dec. 20 to Jan. 5: A flurry of negotiations in between Republican and also Democratic Senate leaders ensue over the holidays, consisting of talk the censuring Clinton rather than hold a trial and possibly removing him from office. The two sides disagree end whether to speak to witnesses, and ultimately opt come wait until after opening arguments from the House and also the White House prior to deciding.
Jan. 5: Senate bulk Leader Trent Lott (R-Miss.) announces Clinton’s psychological will start Jan. 7, but senators proceed to wrangle over exactly how long it must be and whether to speak to witnesses.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman Henry Hyde (R-Ill.), among the home managers, claimed they had little idea of what come expect. “Everything is under negotiation. All kinds the rumors room going around. Time is wasting. We have to agree ~ above a format,” Hyde said.
Jan. 6: Representatives and also senators return to Washington come convene the 106th Congress, and the residence passes a second resolution, to give the residence managers government to action in the new Congress. Lock again inform the Senate that the impeachment articles.
Chief Justice wilhelm H. Rehnquist is sworn in come oversee the impeachment trial of president Clinton in 1999.
Jan. 7: Clinton’s trial for perjury and obstruction that justice starts in the Senate with the swearing-in of chief Justice william H. Rehnquist to preside and also of the senators to sit in judgment.
Hyde leads a procession that the house managers bearing the articles throughout the Rotunda come the Senate and reads them aloud.
Jan. 8: In a closed-door meeting, the Senate unanimously agrees ~ above a procedure for continuing the trial, however puts turn off deciding the sticking suggest — whether to contact witnesses.
The covenant gives the house managers and White house lawyers every 24 hours, spread over number of days, to make their corresponding cases. It allows senators 16 hrs to ask concerns of each side before voting on even if it is to i disbanded the instance or to continue and call witnesses.
(The psychological rules have actually not yet been collection for Trump’s trial, showing the recurring disputes. The Senate is expected to think about something Tuesday.)
Jan. 11: Clinton’s defense team denies the charges versus the chairman in a 13-page answer come a Senate summons. Home managers submit a pretrial memo outlining their case.
(Trump has actually until Saturday evening to respond come the Senate summons approve Thursday. Residence managers must also submit your pretrial short Saturday evening.)
Jan. 13: Clinton’s lawyers paper their pretrial short outlining their instance for the president’s acquittal. Clinton tells reporters he wants to focus on the nation’s business, not the trial. “They have their job to do in the Senate, and I have actually mine,” Clinton says. “And ns intend to do it.”
(Trump’s lawyers have actually until noon Monday to record their brief. The home managers gain until noon Tuesday to paper a rebuttal.)
Jan. 14: Thirteen residence managers start a three-day opened statement suggesting to convict Clinton and remove the from office.
Jan. 19: Clinton’s legit team starts its three-day opened statement. While the lawyers had been intended to contact for dismissing the articles, White home Counsel Charles Ruff makes a detailed, point-by-point rebuttal that the case against Clinton, focusing both directly on the truth of the Lewinsky scandal and broadly on the Constitution’s typical for impeachment.
“We think there are significant holes in the home case, and many overreaching characterizations,” claimed Jim Kennedy, a Clinton spokesman. “We will challenge the allegations through going with the entire record.”
That evening, Clinton delivers the nationally televised State that the Union address to a share session that Congress.
Jan. 22: The senators begin questioning the prosecution and defense teams, passing their written concerns to Rehnquist.
Jan. 23: A judge orders Lewinsky to cooperate with home prosecutors. She return to Washington native California.
Jan. 24: Lewinsky submits to a nearly two-hour interview with residence managers, who left the meeting saying she is “impressive” and “personable” and “would it is in a really helpful witness” if she were called. She lawyers speak it created no brand-new information.
Jan. 25: Senators hear arguments about dismissing the charges against Clinton and then intended in secret.
Jan. 26: Senators hear disagreements from residence managers because that seeking depositions from 3 witnesses — Lewinsky, Clinton confidant Vernon Jordan and White House interactions aide Sidney Blumenthal, and also then intentional in secret.
Jan. 27: In back-to-back 56-44 votes, nearly along party lines, the Senate refuses come dismiss the charges versus Clinton and also agrees to look for depositions native Lewinsky, Jordan and also Blumenthal.
Jan. 28: After failing to reach a bipartisan agreement, the Senate authorize Republicans’ setup for taking depositions in a party-line vote and sets Feb. 12 as a target day for the trial’s end.
Feb. 1: House supervisors depose Lewinsky behind closeup of the door doors. Clinton’s lawyer reads a statement expressing the president’s regret over what she’s unable to do through and asks no questions.
Feb. 2: House supervisors privately concern Jordan for three hours.
Feb. 3: House supervisors question Blumenthal for 3 hours.
Feb. 4: By a 70-30 vote, the Senate decides no to call Lewinsky to testify in person, as residence Republicans wanted, but allows House managers to present video clip excerpts of she deposition.
Feb. 6: House managers and White home lawyers play video clip excerpts the Lewinsky’s deposition on big screens collection up in the Senate, an unmatched departure for a human body that two decades later tho does not permit the day-to-day use of electronic devices by senators, staff or press.
House managers argue the the video clip clips of Lewinsky show that Clinton orchestrated a cover-up of their relationship. White house lawyers speak to the clips selective and also misleading.
Feb. 8: House managers and also Clinton’s lawyers sell closing arguments.
Feb. 9: The Senate begins closed-door deliberations ~ above Clinton’s fate after ~ rejecting a proposal to open the proceedings to the public.
See more: Imax Movies On Carnival Dive In Movie Schedule 2017, November Dive
“The American human being have the best to have actually a full understanding of just how we reached our decisions on this really momentous matter,” Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) says before the vote. “It must be questioned in the light of work so that the American people and future generations fully understand the factors for our votes.”
(Collins, still in the Senate, says she is functioning with several GOP senators to ensure witnesses can be called during the trump trial.)
Clinton is acquitted the both short articles of impeachment. ~ above the perjury charge, 10 Republicans and all 45 democrats vote not guilty. Top top the obstruction-of-justice charge, the Senate splits 50-50.