“I tried with Senator Grassley back in the 1980s to frozen all government spending, including Social Security, including everything,” Biden claimed in 1995.

You are watching: Did biden try to cut social security


*

*

Then0 Sen. Joe Biden prior to his appearance on NBC"s "Meet the Press" in Washington, D.C., top top April 29, 1984, a year the was encountering reelection to the Senate. Photo: Charles Tasnadi/APThen0 Sen. Joe Biden before his appearance on NBC"s "Meet the Press" in Washington, D.C., top top April 29, 1984, a year the was encountering reelection come the Senate. Photo: Charles Tasnadi/AP

As early as 1984 and as newly as 2018, previous Vice chairman Joe Biden called for cuts to Social protection in the name of conserving the program and balancing the commonwealth budget. Critical week, Sen. Bernie Sanders emphasize Biden’s document on Social protection in prosecuting the case that Biden isn’t the many electable candidate. The issue could be elevated again in Tuesday night’s debate.

After a Sanders project newsletter continued the strike on Biden’s Social defense record, the Biden project complained to fact-checkers at Politifact that his comments were gift taken out of context. Inserted in context, however, Biden’s record on Social defense is far worse 보다 one offhand remark. Indeed, Biden has been advocating for cuts to Social defense for roughly 40 years.

And after a Republican wave swept Congress in 1994, Biden’s assistance for cutting social Security, and his basic advocacy for budget plan austerity, made the a leading combatant in the centrist-wing battle against the party’s retreating liberals in the 1980s and also ’90s.

“When I argued that we need to freeze commonwealth spending, I meant Social protection as well,” he told the Senate in 1995. “I intended Medicare and Medicaid. I intended veterans’ benefits. I meant every solitary solitary point in the government. And I not just tried the once, i tried it twice, i tried it a 3rd time, and also I tried it a 4th time.” (A freeze would have diminished the quantity that would certainly be paid out, cut the program’s benefit.)


What Biden was expressing was a typical sentiment amongst the centrist faction that the party in the 1980s and also ’90s — the id that old tax-and-spend liberals to be out, and also that a type of “New Democrat” to be needed, one who understood the need of budget restraint. Cutting spending to be the just way, the argued, to rescue what was left of the great Society and new Deal. The mentality that Biden-style democracy — the the best the party could do was play defense — was leading for a generation; it’s now being fundamentally challenged not simply in the presidential campaign however in congressional primaries throughout the country.


The mentality of Biden-style democrats — that the best the party can do to be play defense — was dominant for a generation, but is now being fundamentally challenged.

Biden himself, at least on his campaign website, now supports making social Security an ext generous, not less. However that’s in ~ odds with decades of his very own advocacy, a document that could end up being a significant political liability among voters came to Biden will finally get his great to trim ago Social security checks. Because about half of black color seniors on Social defense rely top top it together their primary means of support, any kind of trimming that the routine hits those beneficiaries specifically hard.

Over the years, Biden, in speeches and also interviews, has frequently taken pains to let listeners know that he’s acquisition an unpopular stance, gift explicit around the risk he knows he’s taking.

“One that the things my politics advisers say to me, is, whoa, nothing touch that 3rd rail,” Biden told Tim Russert top top “Meet the Press,” while to run for chairman in 2007.

With this year’s presidential contest being battled over the terrain of electability, Biden’s 35-plus-year effort to cut Social Security, maybe the most popular government program in existence, is potentially a major liability amongst older voter — and also hypocrisy has actually never organized Trump earlier from do an reliable political attack. Biden’s historical position likewise stands in stark comparison to Sens. Bernie Sanders and also Elizabeth Warren, both of who support increasing benefits and also have offered ways to do the regime solvent indefinitely.

“As Bernie Sanders himself said in 2015 — after every one of these price quotes — ‘Joe Biden is a man who has committed his entire life come public service and to the wellbeing of working families and the center class,’” said Andrew Bates, a spokesperson for Biden.


“So, as soon as those of my friends in the Democratic and also Republican Party say to me, ‘How do you mean me to vote for her proposal? walk it no freeze Social protection COLAs because that one year? are we no saying there will certainly be no cost-of-living boosts for one year?’ The price to that is ‘Yes, that is what ns am saying,’” Biden claimed in a Senate floor decided in April 1984, referring to the adjustment that millions of seniors look for every year.

Biden was facing reelection to the Senate in 1984, which to be shaping approximately be a heavily Republican cycle, and continued returning to the worry of society Security.

His arrangement with Grassley to be backed, the new York times reported in might 1984, by a bevy of company trade groups, “including the room of commerce of the unified States, the nationwide Federation of live independence Businesses, service Executives for national Security and the national Association of Manufacturers.”

The Biden-Grassley arrangement was at some point rejected, but Biden never ever wavered on it, suggesting in 1988 that had he to be able to cut Social Security, he’d have been able to save other social programs and force republic to reduced defense spending.

“I introduced an amendment, nevertheless my quote free credentials, of freezing the federal budget, absolute freeze,” Biden boasted. “I go it because that a straightforward reason: i sat top top the budget Committee because that 11 years. And also I’d find the very same thing happen every time. We’d start off v grandiose ideas of how we’re walk to reduced the budget. Us would never touch entitlements, us would never ever touch the defense budget, and we couldn’t touch the attention on the debt. Which meant that out of a trillion-dollar budget, the left us just $156 billion and also what we would do annually is we would go out and also cut out education, food stamps, Head Start, payments, on down the line, every little thing that ns cared about got cut, since at the very end, we’d say, ‘Well, we’ve gotta make some cuts.’ and that would certainly be the path of least resistance.”

That political strategy — the by ceding to Republicans, they will respond through compromising in return — has actually been extensively discredited through the critical 40 year of events, despite it remains the animating dispute of Biden’s campaign.

In November 1995, the again reminded the public of his deficit hawkery. “I to be a Democrat the voted for the constitution amendment come balance the budget. I have actually introduced on 4 occasions — four occasions — entire plans come balance a budget,” he claimed on the Senate floor. “I tried with Senator Grassley earlier in the 1980s to frozen all government spending, consisting of Social Security, including everything.”


“When I presented my spending plan freeze proposal years ago, the for free of my party said, ‘It’s an dreadful thing you are doing, Joe. Every the program we care about, you room freezing castle — money for the blind, the disabled, education and so on,’” Biden continued. “My discussion then is one ns make now, i beg your pardon is the strongest, most compelling reason to be for this revised — or an modification — the if we carry out not perform that, every the points I care most about are going to be gone — gone.”

The first couple of months the 1995 to be taken up with controversy over an additional GOP-led balanced budget amendment, v Biden saying forcefully to exclude Social protection from it.

“After the year 2014, we will be in deficit in the Social protection system,” that warned. “It appears pretty clear to me this is about two things: One, they need the Social defense dollars to make the deficit look favor it is less than the is, and then the next step is they space going to require to try to deal with an altering it to boost the quantity of money they get in the trust funds to do the deficit look even less, which means that Social protection is walking to gain hit.”


Biden thrust for an amendment come carve Social protection out the the well balanced budget amendment. Clear as it may have actually been, the revised to safeguard Social security failed. Biden voted because that the well balanced budget modification anyway, even after his lot of warnings that it would certainly undercut society Security.

It was, in fact, the dispute over Social security that torpedoed the balanced budget revised by a solitary vote top top the Senate floor, after the had already passed the House. “After days of persuasion, the Republicans supporting the amendment to be unable to attract the one last vote they essential for a two-thirds majority, resulting in a success for Democrats, who elevated doubts in the last hours about whether the Social security trust fund would be safe if the measure ended up being law,” the new York times reported in march 1995. Biden’s inability to bring along one extr Democratic colleague had saved the program, and saved the structure from being amended through a draconian fiscal constraint mechanism.

Ironically, the budget plan would with balance anyway by the finish of the decade, as commonwealth revenue climbed — the an outcome of an economy in hyperdrive many thanks to a tech bubble. President George W. Bush turned the surplus right into a mammoth tax reduced for the wealthy, and also within just a few years, Biden to be again phone call for cuts to Social security to deal with the deficit.


“The American people know we have to fix social Security,” Biden said in 2007. “They know we’re walking to have to make some difficult decisions.”

In his 2007 interview with Russert as a presidential candidate, the “Meet the Press” host asked, “Senator, we have a deficit. We have Social Security and also Medicare looming. The variety of people on society Security and Medicare is currently 40 million people. That going to it is in 80 million in 15 years. Would you think about looking at those programs, age of eligibility…”

“Absolutely,” Biden said.

“ … price of living, put it every on the table.”

“The price is absolutely,” Biden said, recall Russert that earlier in his career, he had been component of the small variety of senators who had actually come up through the deal that increased the retirement age, and promised to protect each other from voters outraged at the cuts:

I was one of five world — ns was the junior guy in the meeting v Bob Dole and also George Mitchell when we put Social security on the right path because that 60 years. I’ll never forget what Bob Dole said. After ~ we got to an agreement about gradually elevating the retirement age, etc., he said, ‘Look, this is the deal, us all placed our foot in the boat one at a time.’ and he kicked — that stepped favor he to be stepping into a boat. ‘And us all make the complying with deal. If any type of one the the challengers running against the incumbent Democrat or Republicans strike us ~ above this point, fine all continue to be together.’ it is the kind of leadership that is needed. Social Security’s not the hard one come solve. Medicare, that is the gorilla in the room, and also you’ve got to put every one of it top top the table.

At Iowa’s Jefferson-Jackson dinner in November 2007, weeks native the Iowa caucus, Biden again returned to Social Security. “The American civilization know we need to fix society Security,” that said. “They recognize we can’t thrive our method to a solution. They know we’re walking to need to make some difficult decisions. They’re prepared to do those decisions. They’re prepared to action up. We need to be all set to straightforwardly tell them what we’re about to do.”


As angry president, Biden was affiliated in multiple management attempts to reduced Social defense as part of a “grand bargain” v Republicans, every one of them blocked by tea party Republicans, who couldn’t agree to any kind of tax increases. In 2014, Sen. Edge Paul, R-Ky., claimed at a conservative occasion that Biden had privately told him he was sustaining of raising the retirement age and also means-testing Social protection benefits. “I request the evil president, nothing we have to raise the age? i will not ~ means-testing and also raising the age solve the problem?” Paul recounted, through Sens. Ted Cruz and also Mike Lee top top stage, including that Biden said, “Yes in private, but will not say that in public.” Paul hadn’t to be paying close sufficient attention.

A few years later, at a Brookings Institution occasion in April 2018, Biden addressed Social security again. “Paul Ryan to be correct when he walk the taxation code. What’s the an initial thing he decided we had to go after? society Security and also Medicare. Now, we should do something around Social Security and Medicare,” Biden said, then added in a whisper: “That’s the only method you can find room come pay because that it.”

Last week, the Biden project told Politifact the Biden was mocking Ryan and also being sarcastic. Immediately after his whisper, he entered the type of adjustments come Social security he thought must be made, the same form that Paul said he called him sustained privately.

“Now, i don’t know a entirety lot of people in the top one-tenth of 1 percent or the top 1 percent who are relying on society Security once they retire. I don’t know a the majority of them,” Biden said, alluding to the must means-test society Security. “So we need a pro-growth, steady tax code that treats employees as task creators, together well, not simply investors; the gets to escape of unproductive loopholes favor stepped-up basis; and it raises sufficient revenue to make sure that the society Security and also Medicare can stay, that still requirements adjustments, yet can stay; and also pay for the points we all acknowledge will grow the country.”

When the routine is popular, “adjustment” is a Washington euphemism for cuts. Yet you can count on trump card to usage the an ext common term.

Ryan Grim is the writer of the book We’ve gained People: from Jesse Jackson to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the end of huge Money and the climb of a Movement

Update: January 13, 2020, 10:30 a.m.

See more: List Of Celebrities Who Died From Prostate Cancer, 9 Famous Men Who Have Battled Prostate Cancer

The story has actually been updated v a statement native the Biden project sent after ~ publication.


Wait! prior to you go on about your day, asking yourself: just how likely is it the the story you just read would have actually been produced by a various news outlet if The Intercept hadn’t excellent it?Consider what the civilization of media would certainly look prefer without The Intercept. That would organize party elites accountable to the values they proclaim come have? How many covert wars, miscarriages that justice, and also dystopian modern technologies would remain surprise if ours reporters weren’t on the beat?The type of reporting we execute is vital to democracy, but it is not easy, cheap, or profitable. The Intercept is an independent nonprofit news outlet. Us don’t have actually ads, for this reason we rely on our members — 35,000 and counting — to help us organize the an effective to account. Joining is an easy and doesn’t require to cost a lot: you can end up being a maintain member because that as tiny as $3 or $5 a month. That’s every it bring away to support the journalism you count on.BecomeaMember