Lessons from his campaign are an chance for us to be honest about the challenges that LGBTQ candidates face.

You are watching: Did buttigieg drop out of the presidential race


Pete Buttigieg campaign buttons in ~ a rally in ~ Stonewall Inn in new York on June 28.Gabby Jones / Bloomberg via Getty pictures file
By Joe Cabosky, assistant professor at the Hussman college of Journalism and Media at UNC Chapel Hill
It appears so long ago that the first openly gay candidate winner the Iowa caucuses. Mere mainly later, the Pete Buttigieg project is now past tense, together the previous mayor of south Bend, Indiana, announced Sunday that he to be dropping the end of the race for the democratic presidential nomination.

The disparity in between statements of assistance for a gay candidate and also actual voting returns on gay rights are striking.

Wherever that leaves Buttigieg and also his future politics prospects — or any kind of future LGBTQ candidate — this minute affords united state an opportunity to ask ourselves wherein the country as a totality really is in terms of acceptance of LGBTQ candidates.

To it is in clear, ns not suggesting that Buttigieg was not successful only due to the fact that of homophobia. But lessons native this bike do allow us to be honest about the obstacles that LGBTQ candidates face. If these issues may no have acquired a lot of attention in 2020, Buttigieg’s campaign demonstrates how numerous problems that homophobia still remain.

After Buttigieg winner Iowa, I often heard points akin to homophobia not mattering lot anymore. Sure, there to be Rush Limbaugh’s homophobic remarks. Sure, there was the Buttigieg voter in Iowa asking to have her vote back upon discovering he to be married come a man. But these were isolated incidents, no?


All cycle, a Gallup poll was used as an instance of just how accepting Americans have actually become, through 76 percent that those surveyed speak they’d vote for a gay person for president. While the sounds high, that still means one-quarter the the nation admits the it’s a nonstarter. That’s a many votes lost right off the bat.

And as any type of social scientist can tell you, it is a best-case scenario rather than reality. If friend ask someone if lock homophobic, racist or sexist, we recognize there’s a self-reporting bias that minimizes the true level of the problem, together many people aren’t willing to recognize they are — either publicly or to themselves.


It was only 2012 that North Carolina became the most recent state to happen a constitution amendment versus same-sex marriage. If nationally, sixty-eight percent of world that year stated they’d poll for a gay candidate, fewer 보다 39 percent of citizens in this southerly swing state vote for equal rights. Polling showed those opposed included much more than 40 percent the Democrats and the majority of african Americans.

While over there is a difference between voting because that a gay candidate and also supporting marital relationship rights, the disparity in between statements of support for a gay candidate and also actual voting returns on gay legal rights are striking.


This gap in between public statements and also actual voting behavior are implied in other ways. Beyond asking people whether they us are all set for a happy president, pollsters questioning whether civilization think others room ready. The numbers constantly get worse in this formulation. In a Politico/Morning above poll, 50 percent that those surveyed claimed they were prepared to poll for a happy candidate, but only 40 percent thought others were.

These perceptions of others have the right to be a an ext informative window into people’s thoughts. 2 things room implied here. First, it might be an example of how people don’t desire to admit their own perspectives but are willing to do so through blaming others.

Second, it demonstrates what world are experiencing day-to-day in what lock read, watch and interact with, i.e., continuous homophobia. This is comparable to what girlfriend see with racism or sexism. While almost everyone states they’d poll for an afri American or female candidate, we of course recognize racism and sexism are significant obstacles.

This plays out at the ballot box, that course. Study has presented that human being who to speak they’ll vote for an afri American or female candidate, but it may depend on exactly how candidates attend to issues of gyeongju or how feminine they are viewed to be.


More research likewise needs come be done on exactly how the “electability” dispute affects voters who may not it is in homophobic themselves however who might choose an additional candidate who they awareness “can win” if they think the bigotry of others might influence a candidate’s chances.

Then yes overt homophobia, which feeds all of the over dynamics. Limbaugh struck Buttigieg in February as essentially being less of a man since he’s gay, undermining his candidacy because that reasons having actually nothing to do with plan or morality.

Instead, Limbaugh used the phrase “kissing his husband” at least 4 times in just a couple of sentences. Research shows that countless heterosexuals, specifically heterosexual men, are substantially turned off and also even disturbed by gay intimacy, an especially gay male intimacy. Therefore Limbaugh’s diatribe play on many people’s inner-most homophobia.

These dynamics have also played out in locations outside of politics. When there have actually been countless LGBTQ characters and films end the last couple of decades, for instance, marketing materials generally avoid mirroring LGBTQ intimacy if targeting tendency audiences. Meaning, people may it is in OK v watching a gay film as long as they don’t need to watch a gay person being … gay.

Does all this typical a gay candidate can not win? No. Bigotry has actually been overcome before to selected an afri American president, woman governors and LGBTQ senators.

Does every this median a happy candidate cannot win? No. Bigotry has actually been overcome prior to to elect an afri American president, mrs governors and LGBTQ senators. However it does mean that a gay candidate prefer Buttigieg faces challenges that are greater than we maybe want come admit.

And castle come from within the LGBTQ neighborhood as well. The sad irony was the Buttigieg was also attacked for no being “gay enough.” These criticisms came from the an ext progressive or activist left of the LGBTQ population, producing a conundrum because that candidates from minority backgrounds who hold much more moderate location — people that deserve to be an important in basic elections.

See more: Actress Susan Olsen Who Played Cindy From The Brady Bunch Today

Thus, because that every step forward the Buttigieg’s project made because that future candidates, it additionally exposed how much America requirements to go in its acceptance of LGBTQ leaders.


Joe Cabosky is one assistant professor in ~ the Hussman school of Journalism and also Media in ~ UNC Chapel Hill. His work concentrates on the intersection of varied audiences, measurement and creative public relationships strategies.