Singer chris Brown can’t seem to save his hand to himself. Critical week, the artist to be accused of violent attacking an additional woman in ~ his sprawling san Fernando Valley home in Los Angeles. NBC News reported that the Los Angeles Police room is investigating the occurrence as a feasible battery. (Brown"s lawyer did no respond to NBC"s request for comment Tuesday.)

Few can have to be surprised by the headlines, but many that us are wondering just how does someone v such a long background of violence toward women continue to evade serious consequences from both the legitimate system, the music industry and his fanbase.

You are watching: Did chris brown beat up rihanna

In the years because this lenient initial sentence, Brown has actually been tied come a lengthy list that alleged assaults and violent incidents.

Brown shot come fame together a teenager with the relax of his self-titled debut album in 2005, i beg your pardon went twin platinum. He shot to infamy a couple of years later, in 2009, as soon as photographs surfaced that the results of a violent altercation with his then-girlfriend Rihanna. He was charged with felony domestic assault, at some point pleading guilty to one counting of felony assault in a plea transaction that avoided jail time in exchange for community service, counseling, a restraining order and probation. (Brown was later on accused that violating his restraining order and faking several of his ar service and ordered to serve added hours.)

Want an ext articles prefer this? monitor THINK ~ above Instagram to acquire updates on the week"s many important social analysis

In the years since this lenient early sentence, Brown has actually been tied come a lengthy list the alleged assaults and also violent incidents. In enhancement to lot of alleged assaults on fans, staff and other musicians consisting of Frank s in 2017, his ex-girlfriend Karrueche Tran to be granted a restraining order versus him citing physical violence during their relationship and also menacing actions after your split, including threatening to death her. (Brown called the claims b------.)


Two year later, he and members of his entourage to be detained in Paris after gift accused the aggravated rape and also drug possession. Brown refuse the allegations and was released, but subsequently skipped a meeting v French investigators. (His lawyer said the date was “inconvenient” because that Brown however that the wished come “find a brand-new date.”) how does someone through multiple alleged violent assaults versus intimate partners and strangers alike, including rap, proceed to be widely commemorated by fans and also other artists? His last album, “Indigo” included collaborations through Lil Wayne, Tyga and also H.E.R. And became his 3rd No. 1 album ~ above the Billboard 200 chart.

On the one hand, like various other rich and powerful people, Brown benefits from expensive legal representation, a dilemm management team and influential allies. Yet a celebrity is a particular form of rich and an effective person. And while over there is a thirsty to watch the rich and famous punished for their crimes, not all celebrities room treated equally.


This seems specifically true for the music business, which has actually arguably lagged behind Hollywood and other entertainment industries in terms of #MeToo accountability. This may since of powerful economic incentives protecting the standing quo, coupled with conflicting interests throughout record labels, streaming services, display promoters, merchandisers, artists and fans. Adjust is coming, but thus far Chris Brown’s career hasn’t suffered much.

And in this era of alleged cancel society hysteria, Brown has gone reasonably unscathed. Despite some setbacks securing visas to execute internationally and some cancellations in the immediate wake the his attack on Rihanna, he no dropped from his label; he’s been nominated because that multiple Grammys (winning one in 2012); he’s collaborated with major female artists like Nicki Minaj, Brandy and also even Rihanna after ~ the attack; he’s likewise moved into acting, consisting of a insignificant on “Black-ish” alongside Tracee Ellis Ross. Part say he’s in reality benefitted from his bad-boy picture by branding it as one more product for sale.

This seems specifically true because that the music business, which has actually arguably lagged behind Hollywood and other entertainment markets in terms of #MeToo accountability.

There’s a gendered facet to this branding. Gift a tough-talking, talented masculine celebrity with militaries of mrs fans renders a difference. We could ask ourselves why would women in particular continue to support a serial abuser — not just vibing his music, but defending him prefer family. Roxane Gay composed in 2012 the the young women who still love Brown are commodities of a society that normalizes violence versus women; they might think gift roughed increase is a same exchange because that proximity to someone they find physically and financially attractive. And also it’s true the “patriarchy has no gender,” together bell hooks declared to describe how females invest in solution that oppress them.

When it involves music this no a brand-new conversation. In 2004, during his “Never Scared” comedy unique on HBO, chris Rock joked around women loving the many misogynistic rap the he himself had trouble defending. It’s straightforward to fall into a debate about the substance and also style of lyrics, yet I’m more interested in our attachments to the artists themselves, or who we think castle are.

Some fans acquire so invest in your projections the they do more than fanaticize. Brown’s hardcore followers speak to themselves Team Breezy. In enhancement to fawning over his music, they track him and also one another across social media, protect him tirelessly and also threaten his critics. This kind of mega fandom, or stan culture, thrives on society media, wherein fans feel together though they have actually greater access to, and eventually intimacy with, their favorite celebrities. The net blurs real friends digital friends, and also fake friends. This, in turn, have the right to undermine initiatives to hold particular celebrities accountable for abusive behavior.

And too many celebrities quiet circle the wagons for their peers that they’ve worked with or hope to job-related with in the future.

And too many celebrities quiet circle the wagons for their peers that they’ve worked with or expect to work-related with in the future. In 2018, once Spotify announced that wouldremove music native R. Kelly and XXXTentacion, artists like Kendrick Lamar threatened to pull your music unless the streaming business reconsidered. (Lamar said the dominion unfairly targeted artist of color.) in spite of being praised by women’s advocacy groups like UltraViolent — i m sorry urged that kris Brown also be added to the banned perform — Spotify did reverse its policy. While the initial guidelines, which Apple and Pandora were likewise encouraged to adopt, raised an overwhelming questions around what constitutes “hate content” and also whether black color artists to be being singled out, the backlash illustrates the difficulty of holding musicians accountable.

We additionally can’t discount the discomfort many of united state feel going after a Black guy — wealthy or not — and also calling because that his arrest, incarceration or also cancellation. Black men currently face harsher sentences and are overrepresented in prison, and also plenty that white musicians choose Marilyn Manson have actually been together allegedly reckless and also predatory as chris Brown.

These are fair concerns, but we chandelier not use legitimate concerns about the over-incarceration the Black men to forgive the actual abusers in our midst. And bringing up various other celebrities that also need canceling (or arrest) perform not detract native Brown’s misdeeds. The #MeToo movement is no a zero amount game.


“I was recently the victim the an action of violence through a man. ~ a party, ns was shot double as i walked far from him,” created rapper Megan Thee Stallion in 2020, detailing how difficult it deserve to be for black color women"s stories and also problems to be legitimized. Canadian rapper Tory Lanez was charged in the shooting critical summer, yet it is Stallion who has confronted regular ridicule, suspicion and trivialization. She celebrity does no shield she from the expectation that ladies be silent about their emotional and physical abuse.

In 2017, singer Chrisette Michele"s job nosedived ~ she performed in ~ Donald Trump’s inauguration. Her selection to carry out was reportedly considered an ext shocking, more of a betrayal 보다 allegedly raping and also attacking women. Until we challenge this (inescapably gendered) discrepancy about what is considered unacceptable actions from men and women, punishment will never be meted the end equally.

See more: 20% Off Enterprise Coupon For Enterprise Car Rental Codes, Car Rental Deals And Discounts


Robyn Autry is chair of the Sociology room at Wesleyan University. She is the author of "Desegregating the Past: the public Life of memory in the U.S. And also South Africa," and a fellow at the Jackman liberal arts Institute in ~ the college of Toronto.