Jake Tapper reality checks Donald Trump’s repeated insurance claims that Hillary Clinton started the “birther” movement versus Barack Obama in 2008.

" data-duration="04:15" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >

You are watching: Did clinton start the birther movement


now playing
Hillary Clinton defends Bill no resigning
In an interview through elafilador.net’s Christiane Amanpour, Hillary Clinton decried Brett Kavanaugh’s swearing-in ceremony, saying it “further undermined the image and integrity the the court.”

" data-duration="02:12" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="New Day" data-show-url="https://www.elafilador.net/shows/new-day" class="video-playlist__item" >


now playing
Hillary Clinton makes cameo top top 'Murphy Brown'
“There are numerous ways for a conference to hold a chairman accountable,” Hillary Clinton tells Christiane Amanpour in an exclusive interview.

" data-duration="01:47" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
hillary clinton amanpour impeachment_00014522.jpg
now playing
Clinton: Impeachment 'will be left to rather to decide'
In an interview through elafilador.net’s Christiane Amanpour, Hillary Clinton offers her views on Republicans, saying that the party is “ideological” and “driven by the lust because that power.”

" data-duration="03:04" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
hillary clinton republicans amanpour intv vpx_00000000.jpg
currently playing
Clinton: Civility start by electing democracy
former President invoice Clinton ended his tribute in ~ Aretha Franklin’s funeral by letting the late singer speak for herself.

" data-duration="00:55" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="Newsroom" data-show-url="https://elafilador.net/did-clinton-start-the-birther-movement/imager_2_19270_700.jpg" class="video-playlist__item" >
now playing
Clinton end Franklin tribute v smartphone
Responding to a question around allegations that misconduct versus her husband, Hillary Clinton states that he challenged a long investigation, and also that if republic “want a comparison, they must welcome such an examination themselves.”

" data-duration="01:49" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
currently playing
Clinton rejects trumped comparisons to her husband
former President bill Clinton defended himself from current criticism on his affair v Monica Lewinsky, telling NBC’s “Today” he never reached out to the previous White home intern complying with the scandal.

" data-duration="01:58" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="Wolf" data-show-url="https://www.elafilador.net/shows/wolf" class="video-playlist__item" >
Schomburg facility
currently playing
invoice Clinton: ns apologized for Lewinsky scandal
elafilador.net’s Jake Tapper, in partnership with FactCheck.org, looks at Hillary Clinton’s misleading comments around President Trump’s actions come deter Russian choice interference.

" data-duration="04:21" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
US president Donald trump (L) and Russian chairman Vladimir Putin arrive because that a meeting in Helsinki, on July 16, 2018. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski / AFP) (Photo credit need to read BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images)
now playing
reality check: Hillary Clinton's misleading comment
Hillary Clinton go after Syrian president Bashar al-Assad and Russian president Vladimir Putin while speaking at the females in the people Summit in brand-new York.

" data-duration="00:39" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
Angela Weiss/AFP/Getty images
Former united state Secretary of State Hillary Clinton speak at the Eighth annual Women in the world Summit at Lincoln facility for the Performing art on April 6, 2017, in brand-new York City.
currently playing
Hillary Clinton walk after al-Assad, Putin
Hillary Clinton criticized chairman Trump’s relationship with Russia at an occasion in brand-new York City.

" data-duration="01:29" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
stack Kern/WireImage/WireImage
AUSTIN, TX - NOVEMBER 17: former U.S. Secretary the State Hillary Rodham Clinton signs duplicates of her new book "What Happened" in ~ BookPeople top top November 17, 2017 in Austin, Texas. (Photo by rick Kern/WireImage)
currently playing
Clinton: trumped parrots what Putin states
former presidential candidate Hillary Clinton addressed the practice of separating family members at the border, speak the “outcry native every corner of the country” compelled the Trump administration to act.

" data-duration="01:01" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="Wolf" data-show-url="https://www.elafilador.net/shows/wolf" class="video-playlist__item" >
currently playing
Clinton: kids treated together political pawns
on “The Tonight show Starring Jimmy Fallon,” the show’s female writers and also pop star Miley Cyrus wrote thank-you note to Hillary Clinton.

" data-duration="01:15" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
Broadway Video/Universal tv
now playing
Miley Cyrus tears increase thanking Hillary Clinton
justice Ginsburg claims sexism played a prominent component in the 2016 presidential election.

" data-duration="01:50" data-source="elafilador.net" data-show-name="" data-show-url="" class="video-playlist__item" >
RBG ~ above sexism and also HRC_00010727.jpg
currently playing
RBG states Clinton was criticized worse than males
See much more Videos

Story highlights

Trump offered a curt admission tainted through yet another demonstrably false charge

Here"s a look in ~ the basic disputes

See more: Computer Slow On Startup Windows 7 Slow Boot Issues, Top 2 Ways To Fix Windows 7 Slow Boot

elafilador.net —

After more than 5 years of touting “birther” conspiracy theories, Donald trumped on Friday finally conceded a simple truth: “President Barack Obama was born in the unified States.”

he did no apologize or speak come his own function in dispersing the falsehood, i m sorry many people see as an attempt to weaken the legitimacy of America’s an initial black president. Instead, Trump readily available a curt join tainted by yet another demonstrably false charge: that Hillary Clinton and her 2008 primary campaign “started” the racially fee smear.

Both FactCheck.org (working with elafilador.net’s Jake Tapper) and PolitiFact have refuted the pointer on multiple occasions. However the revisionist telling that Clinton was somehow associated persists, many thanks in large part come Trump. He has peddled it for years and also is now promoting it to deflect fist from his very own leading role in advancing the lie.

this is a look in ~ the basic disputes:

did Trump just conjure this allegation versus Clinton out of slim air?

not exactly. The insurance claim predates Trump’s interest in cultivating birtherism.

among the first documented questions about Obama’s provenance come in early on 2007, once the right-wing understanding Magazine reported the researchers v ties come Clinton’s campaign were make the efforts to make hay end his schooling throughout the years he lived in Indonesia. The Clinton team denied this.

The rumor was that Obama to visit a madrassa, or Muslim spiritual school. The connotation, at the very least at the time, would certainly be that he had been education in Islamist or radical anti-American ideology.

but even then, there was no tip Obama had actually been born outside the US.

What have actually Clinton and also her allies stated publicly around birtherism?

there is no proof that Clinton in 2007 or 2008 bolstered, supported or much much less “started” the birther crusade.

and in recent years she has actually repeatedly blasted it, phone call the activity “insidious” in a speech to supporters during an NAACP dinner in May. Critical September, speak to elafilador.net’s Don Lemon top top the “Tom Joyner Morning Show,” Clinton called the idea the she created the birther rumor “ludicrous.”

“First that all,” she added, “(the birther insurance claims are) entirely untrue. And secondly, girlfriend know, the President and also I have actually never had any kind of kind that confrontation choose that.”

Going further back, President bill Clinton in might 2010 denounced birtherism as a “myth.” throughout their major battle and also shortly thereafter, prior to Obama nominated her to it is in secretary of state, Hillary Clinton mostly confronted questions around Obama’s faith. Her denunciations of that whisper campaign weren’t rather as robust as her current language around Trump and the birthers, however she never elevated either falsehood – and certainly was no to reference for beginning them.

but what around claims that top Clinton aides were involved?

supporters of this allegation often tend to point to a memo, written by Clinton pollster mark Penn, and also a conspiratorial email forwarded through a pair of project staffers in 2007.

Penn’s inner note to be titled, “Lack that American Roots,” and also painted media reports about Obama’s time as a boy in Hawaii and Indonesia as having exposed “a very strong weakness for him – his root to an easy American values and culture are at best limited.”

he wrote: “I can not imagine America electing a president throughout a time of war who is no at his center fundamentally American in his thinking and also in his values.”

yet unsavory the sentiment, Penn, who is not working for Clinton’s present campaign, did no at any type of point attend to Obama’s birthplace.

Clinton never ever pursued Penn’s concept as a line of attack. Later on in the year, the campaign dismissed 2 staff members in Iowa that passed along an e-mail that cast Obama together a Muslim certified dealer bent on “destroying the united state from the inside out.”

“Our project does no tolerate this type of task or campaigning,” spokesman Mo Elleithee stated at the time. “As shortly as it pertained to our attention, we asked (the second emailer) to step down.” top top Friday, Clinton 2008 campaign manager, Patti Solis Doyle, denied outright any role starting the movement.

The campaign likewise responded in 2008 come allegations, made by Matt Drudge, the “stressed Clinton staffers” were circulating a photograph of Obama put on a turban through a blanket denunciation.

~ above Friday, the previous Washington bureau chief for McClatchy, James Asher, tweeted that in 2008, Clinton combine Sidney Blumenthal told him “in person” the Obama to be born in Kenya. Blumenthal denied the case to elafilador.net’s Dan Merica, saying Trump “is the one who embraced and supported the birther lie and bears the obligation for it.”

elafilador.net has attempted unsuccessfully to with Asher because that comment. He told his former employer, McClatchy, Friday the he met with Blumenthal in 2008, and that the newspaper chain dispatched a reporter to Kenya come investigate. Nothing come of it. He claimed there already had to be stories released with the allegation before that meeting.

some 2008 staffers called elafilador.net that Blumenthal was no officially part of the Clinton campaign, and a elafilador.net examine of commonwealth Election Commission records shows no payment come Blumenthal native the campaign.

What walk she say about the birther allegations – and also their forerunners – ago then?

In 2007 and 2008, the birther conspiracy largely took a backseat to an additional bogus tale – one that argued Obama, a Christian, was covertly a Muslim.

during a march 2008 interview with “60 Minutes” correspondent Steve Kroft, Clinton claimed she had no expertise of the rumor supported by Drudge. Kroft then asked, “You don’t believe that councilor Obama’s a Muslim?”

This is a transcript of their subsequent exchange:

Clinton: “Of food not. Ns mean, that’s, friend know, over there is no basis because that that. You know, i take that on the communication of what that says. And, you know, there isn’t any type of reason to doubt that.”

Kroft: “And you claimed you’d take Senator Obama in ~ his word that he’s no a Muslim.”

Clinton: “Right, right.”

Kroft: “You don’t believe that he is a Muslim or implying? Right?”

Clinton: “No. No. Why would certainly I? No, over there is nothing to base that on – as much as i know.”

Kroft: “It’s simply scurrilous –”

Clinton: “Look, I have actually been the target that so numerous ridiculous rumors the I have actually a an excellent deal the sympathy for anybody who gets, friend know, smeared v the kind of rumors that go on all the time.”

yet Clinton’s usage of 5 words – “as far as i know” – triggered outrage from countless Obama supporters. Critics argued that they left the door open up for unsavory innuendo.

might Clinton have actually been more forceful in pushing earlier on the rumors? Yes.

Is there evidence that she or top project officials i stopped the fire the Trump and assorted best wingers have actually openly and gleefully fueled in public for years? No.

for this reason why is trump card trying to blame birtherism ~ above Clinton now?

Trump’s decision come backtrack ~ above the birther worry – and also pin that on Clinton – is likely a project tactical move designed to boost his standing v moderate voter who could be susceptible to charges that Trump is racist.

follow a elafilador.net/ORC poll indigenous September 2015, 80% the adults stated they thought Obama was born in the US. Less than half of the dissenters chalked it up an ext to your suspicions than the existence of any type of legitimate evidence.

The exact same survey uncovered that 61% of Trump’s very own supporters did no subscribe to birther rumors, therefore the campaign likely thought about that the had more to gain than to lose by dropping this together a wedge concern in his race against Clinton.