Bureaucratic hurdles showed up to have prevented a hospital delivery in brand-new York City native being completely used.

You are watching: Did cuomo send covid to nursing home

Published27 might 2020

Share on facebookshare on TwitterShare ~ above PinterestShare top top RedditShare via Email


On march 25, Cuomo and the state new York wellness Department directed the recovering COVID-19 patient be discharged from hospitals and also sent come nursing homes. At least 4,500 patient were sent out to “already vulnerable” education homes, follow to data compiled through The associated Press (AP). Numerous blamed the controversial order for more than 5,800 deaths in nursing and also adult treatment facilities in new York, much more than in any type of other state. 

That order, native the office of new York State health and wellness Commissioner Howard Zucker, came amid a “scramble come provide much more hospital beds.” The bespeak said: 

There is an urgent require to broaden hospital volume in brand-new York State to have the ability to meet the need for patients v COVID-19 requiring acute care. As a result, this directive is gift issued come clarify expectations for nursing houses (NHs) receiving occupants returning from hospitalization and for NHs accepting brand-new admissions.

The plan, according to AP, conveniently came under attack:

“It to be the solitary dumbest decision anyone can make if they wanted to death people,” Daniel Arbeeny stated of the directive, which prompted him to pull his 88-year-old father out of a Brooklyn nursing house where much more than 50 civilization have died. His dad later died of COVID-19 at home.

“This isn’t rocket science,” Arbeeny said. “We knew the most vulnerable — the elderly and also compromised — are in parenting homes and also rehab centers.”

On might 10, Cuomo reversed the order, saying now only patients who tested an adverse for the virus could be released to education homes. He continued to safeguard the decision, suggesting he was adhering to the Centers for an illness Control and also Prevention (CDC) and Centers for Medicare and Medicaid services (CMS) guidelines. He likewise said: 

“Any education home can just say, ‘I can’t handle a COVID person in my facility,’” he said, return the in march 25 order didn’t specify just how homes could refuse, saying the ”no resident shall be refuse re-admission or join to the (nursing home) specifically based” on shown or doubt COVID-19.

Meanwhile, at the end of March, according to The brand-new York Times, the USNS comfort was sent out to brand-new York City to aid hospitals overburdened through COVID-19 patients by acquisition on non-coronavirus cases. U.S. Chairman Donald trump himself supervised the ship’s departure from Norfolk, Virginia. But on April 2, the 1,000-bed facility only had 20 patients. 

A combination of armed forces protocols and bureaucratic hurdles prevent the delivery from accepting many patients, frustrating plenty of hospital leaders. The brand-new York time report outlined the hurdles that restricted patient input in beforehand April: 

On height of its strict rules staying clear of people infected through the virus from coming on board, the marine is also refusing come treat a hold of various other conditions. Accuse disseminated to hospitals included a list of 49 medical conditions that would exclude a patient from admittance come the ship.

Ambulances cannot take it patients straight to the Comfort; castle must first deliver patient to a city hospital because that a prolonged evaluation — including a test because that the virus — and also then pick them up again for transfer to the ship.

At the exact same time, follow to the Times, the variety of non-COVID-19 patient in new York City hospitals had actually dropped: 

… there is not a high volume of noncoronavirus patients. Since most new Yorkers have actually isolated us in your homes, there room fewer injuries from automobile accidents, pistol shots and also construction accidents that would need an emergency room visit.

Michael Dowling, head of new York’s largest hospital system, expressed his frustration end the hurdles gaining patients to the hospital ship:

Ultimately, Mr. Dowling and others said, if the lull refuses to take Covid patients, over there are few patients to send. And given the pernicious spread out of the condition in new York City, where practically 50,000 were infected together of Thursday, dividing patients into those who have it and also those who perform not is pointless, the said.

See more: Complete Freeze On Federal Workforce Hiring Freeze, The Impacts Of The Federal Hiring Freeze

The solution, he and also others said, to be to open the lull to patients v Covid-19.

“It’s quite ridiculous,” that said. “If you’re not going to assist us through the human being we need assist with, those the purpose?”

On April 6, Cuomo inquiry Trump because that permission come treat coronavirus patients on the ship. Trump card agreed, and also the marine reconfigured the ship right into a 500-bed hospital so the could space out patient to protect against spreading the disease. Yet on that exact same day, a crew member tested optimistic for the disease, even after the crew had actually been ordered come quarantine for 2 weeks before their departure for new York. The number of infected prospered to 4 in the complying with weeks. By April 21, the ship had actually treated only 179 patients, not even close to its capacity. 

Trump acknowledged during a White residence briefing that the factor the ship wasn’t put to much use was due to the fact that its arrival synchronized with the opening of a military-supported short-lived hospital in ~ the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center. A command of the Comfort’s task pressure supporting the COVID-19 mission in new York City echoed the sentiment:

Combined, “we make a pretty far-reaching impact,” O’Brien said. “But the truth is the hospitals to be able to double the number of ICU beds virtually in the time that us were here.”

“We had the extra volume – if the was required – and fortunately it no needed,” the added. “So i think the is a win.”

The Javits center’s makeshift hospital treated approximately 1,000 patients during its run, and also was closed by may 1 after it showed up that brand-new York City was previous the top of the pandemic. Days before, Cuomo met Trump in ~ the White House, whereby the chairman asked him about relocating the Comfort back to its base where it might be dispatched to various other locations. Cuomo later on told MSNBC that the state no much longer needed the hospital ship. Right a month ~ the delivery arrived in brand-new York, it returned to Norfolk. 

In summary, Cuomo’s management did worry a controversial directive that sent recovering COVID-19 patients to education homes, which might have contributed to a spike in COVID-19-related deaths in those facilities. Officials reversed the order in May. The USNS Comfort’s inability to take it in an ext patients was due to a mix of governmental hurdles for new York City hospitals who found it difficult to send patients to the delivery in the an initial place. Also after the ship opened up to treating COVID-19 patients, it was still unable to fill every one of its beds. Therefore, we price this case as a “Mixture.”